DEVELOPMENT PREVIEW · Proposition 2.5 and supporting visuals are still being edited · Not for public launch
DevolvED
Proposition 2.5 · Chapter 1 of 7

People, place and human flourishing

Working chapter preview. Text, illustrations, pop-outs and references remain subject to final editorial review.

1. Human Flourishing, Place and the Purpose of Devolution

1.1 From Public Purpose to Public Value

The proposition developed in the Introduction raises a question fundamental to the future of English devolution: how should the success of regional government be understood and evaluated? The distribution of powers, the adequacy of funding, the legitimacy of decisions and the effectiveness of individual institutions are indispensable considerations, but they do not provide a complete account of the purposes that public governance should serve. If the development of people and the development of place are mutually reinforcing, the success of a devolved settlement must also be considered through the opportunities it creates, the capabilities it enables individuals and communities to develop, and the contribution it makes to forms of prosperity that are economically productive, socially inclusive and sustainable over time.

This distinction matters because institutional reform can acquire a momentum of its own. The establishment of authorities, the transfer of responsibilities and the negotiation of agreements may be regarded as evidence of progress, even where their contribution to public wellbeing or institutional effectiveness remains uncertain. A regional strategy may express admirable ambitions without materially changing the decisions of participating organisations, while a partnership may establish extensive processes for cooperation without creating benefits that could not have been achieved through existing arrangements. A more demanding conception of success would distinguish the machinery through which public responsibilities are exercised from the value that machinery enables. It would ask not merely whether organisations have become better connected, but whether those connections have improved decisions, strengthened capabilities or expanded opportunities in ways that justify the resources and responsibilities involved.

The concept of public value offers a useful framework for considering this challenge. In Creating Public Value, Mark Moore (1995) examines the relationship between the substantive value public organisations seek to create, the legitimacy and support necessary to pursue that value, and the operational capabilities required to achieve it. This perspective is particularly relevant to regional governance because the pursuit of shared outcomes does not remove the distinct sources of authority upon which participating institutions depend. Public purposes must be capable of securing democratic and institutional legitimacy; ambitions must be matched by the resources, expertise and responsibilities necessary for delivery; and claims of public benefit must be tested against evidence rather than inferred from the existence of cooperation.

Applied to DevolvED, this approach suggests that regional governance should be judged partly by the additional public value arising from relationships between institutions. National government, regional democratic leadership, local authorities, educational providers, enterprises and public services possess different responsibilities and forms of accountability, but their activities may influence outcomes experienced collectively by individuals and communities. A college may provide excellent teaching while learners face transport barriers beyond its control; a university may undertake valuable research whose wider applications depend upon relationships with enterprises and public services; and a regional authority may possess investment responsibilities that influence access to educational and employment opportunities without exercising authority over educational provision itself. The relevant question is whether more purposeful relationships between these institutions could enable them to achieve benefits that their separate responsibilities do not readily secure.

Such an approach must not confuse shared purpose with common institutional control. Professional independence, statutory responsibilities, democratic accountability and the rights of individuals remain essential to legitimate public governance. Nor does a wider understanding of public value diminish the importance of organisational performance. Effective teaching, financial stewardship, professional standards and lawful decision-making remain necessary conditions for public benefit. The proposition is instead that these responsibilities should be considered alongside the opportunities and outcomes arising from their relationships with one another, particularly where those relationships may contribute to the development of human capability.

[POP-OUT BOX 1 — THE PURPOSE OF DEVOLUTION]

The success of devolution should not be measured principally by the powers transferred, but by the additional opportunities, capabilities and public value those powers help create.

1.2 Human Flourishing and the Capabilities Approach

Human flourishing provides an intellectual foundation for considering what public value should ultimately mean for individuals and communities. It is not reducible to personal satisfaction, economic security or participation in employment, although each may contribute significantly to a fulfilling life. Rather, it concerns the conditions through which people can develop their abilities, acquire knowledge, enjoy health and wellbeing, establish relationships, participate in society, exercise meaningful choice and pursue purposes they have reason to value. This understanding recognises that individuals have different aspirations and circumstances, and that the opportunities required to live a fulfilling life cannot be adequately represented by a single economic or institutional measure.

The capabilities approach associated with Amartya Sen offers a particularly valuable perspective. In Development as Freedom, Sen (1999) challenges accounts of development that rely principally upon income, wealth or aggregate economic performance, arguing that development must also be understood through the substantive freedoms available to individuals. The distinction is important because the possession of resources, or the formal availability of services, does not necessarily establish that people can convert them into meaningful opportunities. Individuals differ in their circumstances, needs and capacities to benefit from provision, while the social and institutional environments in which they live influence what they are genuinely able to achieve.

Consider two young people who have access to similar educational provision and possess comparable academic potential. One may benefit from secure housing, reliable transport, family support, financial stability and established networks through which information about further opportunities is readily available. The other may experience persistent ill health, caring responsibilities, insecure accommodation, financial hardship or limited access to guidance. Although the formal educational entitlement may be similar, the practical opportunities available to these individuals can differ substantially. Their circumstances may influence attendance, the capacity to undertake additional learning, the affordability of progression and the confidence with which they approach unfamiliar institutions or opportunities. The distinction is not between deserving and undeserving individuals, but between the availability of provision and the conditions through which people are able to benefit from it.

The same principle applies to communities and regions. The presence of a university, college, hospital, employment centre or transport connection does not automatically establish that its benefits are accessible to everyone living nearby. Geography, affordability, information, disability, personal circumstances and institutional relationships influence whether potential opportunities become genuine possibilities. A specialist course may exist within a region but remain effectively inaccessible to a learner who cannot afford the journey. Employment opportunities may expand without benefiting individuals who lack the necessary preparation, support or means of participation. Equally, public investment may improve the physical availability of services while leaving significant inequalities in people's ability to use them. The capabilities approach directs attention towards these differences between what is provided and what individuals are substantively able to do.

This does not make conventional measures of performance unimportant. Educational attainment, employment, productivity, earnings, health outcomes and the effectiveness of public expenditure remain essential indicators of progress. Nor does human flourishing provide an argument for reducing expectations of institutions or abandoning the pursuit of economic growth. Productive economies, meaningful employment, enterprise and investment create resources and opportunities upon which individual and collective wellbeing depend. The capabilities approach asks whether these achievements are interpreted within a sufficiently comprehensive understanding of development, including the distribution of opportunities and the extent to which individuals can exercise agency over their lives.

A region experiencing rising productivity while substantial groups remain excluded from education, employment or civic participation cannot be considered wholly successful. Equally, a region with improving public services but limited economic renewal may struggle to sustain those improvements or provide the opportunities its population requires. Human flourishing therefore provides neither an alternative to prosperity nor an excuse for avoiding demanding performance expectations. It offers a broader conception of the purposes for which economic and institutional achievements matter. For DevolvED, the implication is that regional development should be evaluated partly by the extent to which it expands substantive opportunities, particularly for those whose circumstances currently restrict their ability to participate and contribute.

This is an ethical proposition with practical consequences. It influences how policy problems are defined, how investment decisions are appraised, how institutions understand the relationships between their responsibilities and how public value is assessed. It also raises questions about the geographical and social circumstances through which capabilities develop. Those questions are central to the relationship between people and place.

1.3 Place, Opportunity and the Conditions of Participation

Human capabilities develop within particular social, economic, cultural and geographical circumstances. Places differ in their histories, industrial structures, educational institutions, demographic characteristics, cultural resources, environmental conditions and patterns of public and private investment. These differences influence both the opportunities available to individuals and the capacity of institutions to respond to changing circumstances. National entitlements may establish common expectations, but the practical experience of accessing and benefiting from those entitlements can vary considerably between communities. The availability of appropriate courses, the affordability of transport, proximity to specialist services, access to digital infrastructure and the presence of employers or research institutions can all influence educational participation and progression.

The wider determinants of health provide compelling evidence of the significance of these relationships. The Marmot Review's reassessment of health inequalities in England demonstrated the continuing importance of education, employment, income, living conditions and the circumstances of communities in shaping health outcomes (Marmot et al., 2020). Its findings reinforced the principle that health inequalities cannot be understood or addressed adequately through healthcare provision alone. The conditions in which people are born, grow, learn, work and live influence their health and wellbeing, while unequal opportunities to achieve good health can compound other forms of social and economic disadvantage.

The significance for DevolvED extends beyond health policy. Educational participation may be affected by illness, insecure housing or financial hardship; limited transport may restrict access to learning, employment, healthcare and cultural opportunities; and poor educational experiences can influence later economic participation and the circumstances of future families. These relationships are neither uniform nor inevitable, and they do not establish that every difficulty possesses the same cause or requires a common institutional response. They do, however, demonstrate why outcomes pursued through separate public services may depend upon conditions that extend beyond the authority or capability of any one organisation.

This has important implications for the design and evaluation of public investment. A policy concerned solely with the number of facilities established, courses provided or services delivered may offer an incomplete account of its contribution to opportunity. A more comprehensive approach would consider whether people can reach, afford, understand and benefit from that provision, and whether the conditions necessary for meaningful participation are present. It would also recognise that improvements in one area may influence outcomes elsewhere, while avoiding the assumption that every possible benefit will materialise or that the same benefit can legitimately be counted more than once.

[ILLUSTRATION 1 — FROM PUBLIC PROVISION TO HUMAN CAPABILITY]

Retain the three connected dimensions of the existing illustration:

Public and institutional provision — education, health, housing, transport, employment support and community facilities.

Conditions of access and participation — affordability, inclusion, information, mobility, personal circumstances and institutional relationships.

Human capabilities and outcomes — learning, agency, wellbeing, participation, opportunity and contribution.

Central message: providing a service is not always equivalent to enabling an individual to benefit from it.

Recognising the importance of place does not diminish the responsibility of national government to protect standards, entitlements and equity. Indeed, the uneven distribution of institutional resources and capacity may make national stewardship and redistribution especially important. Greater regional discretion, if introduced without appropriate safeguards, could reinforce existing inequalities rather than reduce them. The purpose of place-sensitive policy should therefore be to strengthen the effectiveness of national commitments by recognising the different circumstances through which those commitments must be realised. Regional action may be valuable where it can address identifiable barriers or opportunities arising from local conditions, but it must remain consistent with lawful responsibilities and the wider public interest.

1.4 The Reciprocal Development of People and Place

The relationship between human development and regional prosperity operates in both directions. Places influence the opportunities and capabilities of their populations through the quality of educational institutions, public services, infrastructure, employment, cultural life and environmental conditions. At the same time, the knowledge, creativity, health, skills, enterprise and participation of people influence the development of those places. This reciprocal relationship is central to DevolvED because it challenges an understanding of regional development in which economic structures are treated as largely predetermined and education is expected principally to provide the workforce necessary to sustain them.

A region's future is shaped by its existing industries, physical assets, investment and wider economic circumstances, but also by its capacity to generate knowledge, develop new capabilities, support innovation and establish productive relationships. Schools contribute foundations of knowledge, understanding and intellectual curiosity. Further education colleges develop technical expertise, applied learning and relationships with employers and communities. Universities generate and disseminate knowledge, undertake research, develop professional capability and connect regional institutions with wider intellectual and scientific networks. Enterprises contribute investment, practical knowledge and the capacity to translate innovation into products, services and employment. Public institutions can create opportunities for professional development, research application and improvements in service provision, while community and voluntary organisations bring knowledge of lived experience, local aspirations and forms of participation that may otherwise remain insufficiently recognised.

These contributions are not interchangeable, and their value arises partly from their distinctive purposes and forms of expertise. Effective regional cooperation should not seek to dissolve these differences or impose a single institutional objective. It should examine where relationships between complementary capabilities can create opportunities that would otherwise remain difficult to realise. Research may generate knowledge whose application depends upon technical expertise and enterprise investment; colleges may enable organisations to adopt unfamiliar technologies; public services may identify challenges requiring collaboration across professional and research disciplines; and community organisations may contribute understanding of needs and circumstances that formal institutional processes do not fully capture. Such relationships may already exist and operate effectively, while others may be constrained by limited awareness, fragmented funding, incompatible planning horizons or insufficient opportunities for sustained cooperation.

The OECD's analysis of place-based policies provides a relevant international perspective, emphasising the importance of recognising local conditions, coordinating across sectors and levels of government, and designing interventions around the opportunities and constraints of particular places (OECD, 2025). The significance of this perspective is not that all public policy should become regionally determined, but that some opportunities and barriers are best understood through the relationships between institutions, communities and the economic circumstances of place. National policy remains essential to common entitlements, standards and redistribution; regional leadership may contribute where its legitimate responsibilities and strategic influence enable complementary action; and independent institutions retain the authority and accountability necessary to fulfil their distinctive purposes.

[POP-OUT BOX 2 — THE RECIPROCAL PRINCIPLE]

The development of people strengthens the possibilities of place; the development of place expands the possibilities available to people.

This understanding has particular significance for economic strategy. If education is regarded primarily as a means of supplying labour to existing industries, regional development may become excessively responsive to present economic structures and forecasts. Such responsiveness is necessary but insufficient. Education, research and enterprise can also create new possibilities, stimulate innovation and enable communities to pursue futures that are not yet reflected in established patterns of employment. A more generative relationship between education and prosperity would therefore recognise that the development of human capability is not simply a response to regional economic change, but one of the means through which that change occurs. The objective is not only to prepare people for the region as it exists, but to strengthen their capacity to participate in creating what the region might become.

1.5 Education, Agency and the Whole Learner Journey

Education occupies a foundational position within this conception of human flourishing because it contributes to the knowledge, understanding and judgement through which individuals exercise agency. Its significance extends beyond the acquisition of qualifications or preparation for employment, although both remain indispensable. Through education, people encounter ideas and experiences beyond their immediate circumstances, develop the capacity to examine evidence and question assumptions, and acquire intellectual and practical resources through which they can make decisions about their lives. Education contributes to democratic participation, cultural understanding, creativity and the ability to respond to an uncertain future. Its wider purposes should not be reduced to immediate economic utility, just as its economic contribution should not be overlooked.

The relationship between education and agency becomes particularly important during adolescence and early adulthood. The years between 14 and 25 encompass substantial changes in knowledge, identity, independence, relationships and responsibility, alongside decisions that may influence later opportunities. Young people follow different routes through these years. Some progress through established academic pathways, while others pursue technical education, apprenticeships, employment combined with learning, or routes involving changes of direction and periods of additional support. A system concerned with human capability should recognise the legitimacy of this diversity, maintaining high expectations and credible progression without assuming that one institutional pathway represents the preferred measure of success.

The individual experiences development as a continuing process, even where educational and public-service responsibilities divide that process into separate stages. Movement from school into post-16 education may involve changes in guidance, transport, financial support and specialist provision, while progression into higher education, technical training or employment can introduce further discontinuities. These boundaries may be navigated successfully by many young people, but they can present particular difficulties for those experiencing disability, care responsibilities, economic disadvantage, health difficulties or other circumstances requiring coordinated support. The philosophical significance is that educational opportunity should be considered through the continuity of the person's development rather than solely through the performance of institutions at successive stages.

A more connected regional approach could examine whether participating institutions are able to support that continuity more effectively, without creating a single organisation responsible for every stage or imposing predetermined routes through education. Schools, academy trusts, colleges, universities, employers and relevant public services would continue to discharge their own responsibilities, but could consider where better information, cooperation or access to opportunities might improve the experiences of learners. The practical evidence and institutional implications of these transitions are examined in Section 2, while Section 3 develops the possible contribution of a Regional Education Strategy and the exploratory ideas associated with Every Future Matters and Learning with Purpose.

The relationship between education and place also extends beyond institutional transitions. Regions possess resources for learning through their research institutions, enterprises, cultural organisations, public services, natural environments and communities. These can offer opportunities for learners to encounter authentic questions, apply knowledge, develop judgement and understand the ways in which intellectual and practical capabilities contribute to society. Such experiences must complement, rather than displace, rigorous disciplinary learning. Their educational value depends upon appropriate design, teaching, assessment and evidence of effectiveness, not upon the assumption that activity outside conventional classrooms is inherently superior.

This conception also recognises young people as potential contributors to their communities rather than merely future recipients of economic opportunity. With appropriate knowledge, support and opportunities, they can participate in inquiry, creativity, enterprise and the consideration of challenges affecting the places in which they live. The principle extends throughout adult life. Technological change, economic restructuring, longer working lives and changing personal circumstances create continuing needs and opportunities for learning, professional renewal and participation. A regional strategy concerned with flourishing must therefore recognise lifelong learning as part of the continuing development of human capability, not simply as a response to immediate shortages of labour.

1.6 Public Value and the Responsibilities of Institutions

A shared ambition for human flourishing raises questions about how the contribution of individual institutions and their relationships should be evaluated. The public value framework introduced in Section 1.1 provides a starting point, but its practical application requires a distinction between organisational performance and wider public benefit. Institutions must remain accountable for the quality, legality, financial sustainability and effectiveness of their own activities. These responsibilities cannot be displaced by collective aspirations. Nevertheless, the public value created through institutional activity may extend beyond the boundaries within which organisational performance is normally measured.

A college may deliver high-quality provision while learners face attendance barriers arising from transport difficulties. A university may conduct excellent research without its findings being readily accessible to enterprises or public services that could benefit from them. A health organisation may provide effective treatment while social conditions continue to generate avoidable demand. Such examples do not establish that the institutions concerned are performing inadequately. They illustrate circumstances in which the wider benefits of institutional activity may depend partly upon decisions, resources or relationships beyond the organisation itself. They also raise the possibility that more purposeful cooperation could improve outcomes without transferring responsibility for those outcomes to a single regional body.

This distinction has implications for evaluation. Conventional measures such as attainment, qualifications, research quality, employment, productivity and service efficiency remain essential. A wider public-value perspective would supplement them by asking whether people can use their learning to pursue meaningful opportunities, whether knowledge contributes to innovation and social development, whether services collectively improve people's experiences, and whether the benefits of investment are accessible across different communities. It would also examine whether the costs of coordination are proportionate and whether any improvement can reasonably be attributed to the cooperation being proposed.

[TABLE 1 — FROM INSTITUTIONAL PERFORMANCE TO SHARED PUBLIC VALUE]

The table supplements established performance measures; it does not propose replacing them.

The pursuit of shared public value also raises questions of legitimacy and participation. Regional priorities should not be determined solely by institutional leaders, technical experts or economic stakeholders, however valuable their knowledge may be. Communities and citizens should have meaningful opportunities to influence the purposes pursued in their name and to contribute evidence about the circumstances affecting their lives. Universities and other research organisations can make a distinctive contribution through independent inquiry, evaluation and civic engagement, but their responsibility is not to endorse regional strategies uncritically. Their capacity to challenge assumptions and examine evidence independently is itself a source of public value.

The evaluation of collective outcomes must therefore respect differentiated accountability. An institution should be judged against the responsibilities and commitments it lawfully possesses, while the wider partnership should be examined for the additional benefits its relationships create. Where outcomes depend upon several organisations, evaluation must distinguish between their individual contributions, the effects of cooperation and wider changes that may have occurred independently. This approach is more demanding than simply identifying shared indicators or reporting aggregate improvements, but it is necessary if regional collaboration is to command confidence among government, institutions and communities.

1.7 The Limits and Responsibilities of Regional Collaboration

The intellectual case for human flourishing, place-sensitive development and shared public value does not, by itself, justify the establishment of new regional governance arrangements. England already possesses extensive mechanisms for cooperation across education, skills, economic development, health and public services, many of which produce valuable outcomes. Any additional strategy, agreement or partnership must therefore establish what it would contribute beyond existing arrangements, why those benefits could not be achieved more simply and whether the expected value justifies the resources and responsibilities involved.

The attraction of integrated policy can encourage the assumption that greater coordination necessarily produces better outcomes. Yet collaboration carries costs as well as potential benefits. It can consume leadership capacity, generate additional reporting requirements, slow decisions and obscure responsibility where authority is poorly defined. It may also privilege organisations with the resources and expertise to participate extensively, leaving smaller institutions or less influential communities with limited opportunities to shape collective priorities. A credible regional approach must therefore be selective and proportionate, concentrating on circumstances where institutional relationships create identifiable barriers or where complementary capabilities could generate additional value.

The appropriate geographical scale and institutional arrangements may also differ between functions. National educational standards and statutory entitlements require national stewardship, while local authorities retain duties that cannot be displaced through voluntary partnership agreements. Academy trusts, schools, further education colleges and universities operate through distinctive legal and governance arrangements, and health organisations, enterprises and community bodies possess different responsibilities and forms of accountability. Mayoral strategic authorities may contribute through democratic leadership, strategic convening, investment and functions lawfully assigned to them, but their influence should not be confused with authority over institutions or responsibilities they do not control.

DevolvED proposes three complementary instruments for consideration: a Regional Education Strategy to articulate shared ambition; a National–Regional Partnership Agreement to clarify commitments between authorised governmental parties; and a Regional Education and Prosperity Agreement through which willing institutions might establish separately authorised commitments to cooperation. These instruments are developed in detail in Section 5. At this stage, their significance lies in the possibility of creating clearer relationships between existing responsibilities rather than establishing a hierarchy of regional institutional control. None could override statutory requirements, bind non-participating organisations or substitute collective aspiration for legitimate decision-making authority.

The appropriate response is therefore to investigate where more purposeful cooperation might be necessary, feasible and valuable. Discovery would need to examine the effectiveness of existing arrangements, the risks of duplication and bureaucracy, differences in institutional capacity, the clarity of accountability and the distribution of potential benefits. It should also remain open to the possibility that the objectives identified could be achieved more effectively through changes within existing institutions or partnerships. The ambition of DevolvED is not to maximise collaboration, but to establish whether better relationships can make a demonstrable contribution to human capability and regional prosperity.

1.8 From Intellectual Foundation to Practical Proposition

The concepts developed in this section provide a framework for reconsidering the purposes and evaluation of regional policy. Human flourishing directs attention towards the substantive opportunities available to individuals; the capabilities approach distinguishes formal provision from people's ability to benefit from it; place-sensitive development recognises the circumstances through which opportunities are created and constrained; and public value requires institutions and government to consider both the legitimacy and effectiveness of their activities and the additional benefits arising from their relationships. Together, these ideas suggest that the success of devolution should be judged through a broader understanding of opportunity, capability and prosperity, without diminishing the importance of economic performance, national standards or institutional accountability.

They do not prescribe a particular model of regional government. Instead, they establish questions that any proposed settlement must be capable of answering. Where do the circumstances of place create barriers to opportunity that individual institutions cannot adequately address? Where might education, research, enterprise and public services contribute more effectively through cooperation? What responsibilities and resources would be necessary to achieve those benefits, and how could the arrangements be established without weakening existing accountability? Above all, what evidence would demonstrate that a more connected approach creates public value beyond that available through established mechanisms?

These questions provide the bridge from intellectual foundation to practical investigation. Before considering the institutional instruments through which a Regional Education Strategy might operate, it is necessary to examine the inequalities, transitions and relationships that shape the opportunities available to people. The following section therefore turns to the evidence and circumstances that may justify a more connected regional ecosystem, distinguishing problems of institutional performance from barriers arising through wider social conditions and the relationships between organisations.

[POP-OUT BOX 3 — THE TEST OF REFORM]

The ultimate test of DevolvED is not whether institutions become more connected on paper. It is whether those connections create opportunities and public value that would otherwise remain unrealised.

The purpose of devolution should be to expand what people and places are capable of becoming.

That is the standard against which this proposition should be judged.

Publication status — working draft