DEVELOPMENT PREVIEW · Proposition 2.5 and supporting visuals are still being edited · Not for public launch
DevolvED
Proposition 2.5 · Chapter 2 of 7

Fragmented opportunity and public value

Working chapter preview. Text, illustrations, pop-outs and references remain subject to final editorial review.

2. People, Place and Public Value — The Case for a More Connected Regional Ecosystem

2.1 The Unequal Geography of Opportunity

The intellectual foundations developed in Section 1 suggest that the success of public policy should be understood partly through the capabilities and opportunities available to individuals and communities. This perspective becomes particularly significant when considered against the unequal geography of opportunity in England. Educational attainment, health, employment, income, access to services and participation in civic and cultural life vary between places and across different groups within them. These differences reflect complex histories of economic development, investment, institutional capacity and social circumstances. They also influence the resources, relationships and confidence through which individuals are able to pursue their aspirations. The challenge for regional policy is therefore not simply to improve aggregate performance, but to understand how the circumstances of place shape the opportunities available to people and the extent to which public institutions are able to respond.

The consequences of disadvantage can accumulate across the course of a person's life. A child growing up in a household experiencing financial insecurity may encounter difficulties that influence health, attendance, access to learning resources and participation in wider educational experiences. Those circumstances can affect later choices and progression, while limited access to suitable employment, housing or transport may compound the challenges faced during adulthood. The relationships are neither uniform nor deterministic: individuals and communities demonstrate considerable resilience, ambition and achievement in difficult circumstances. Nevertheless, the interaction of social, economic and institutional conditions helps explain why the formal availability of public services does not necessarily produce equivalent opportunities to benefit from them.

Educational institutions occupy a central position within this landscape. High-quality teaching, ambitious curricula, effective leadership, appropriate support and strong accountability are indispensable to educational improvement. Differences in institutional performance must be examined directly, and wider social explanations should never become an excuse for accepting weak provision or diminished expectations. Yet educational outcomes cannot be understood exclusively through the activities of schools and colleges. Family circumstances, housing stability, health, financial security, transport accessibility and the availability of cultural and educational experiences can influence participation and progression. The effectiveness of educational provision therefore depends partly upon conditions that institutions may influence but cannot independently control.

The OECD's analysis of place-based policies recognises that economic and social challenges differ between regions and that nationally uniform approaches may be insufficient where opportunities and constraints are shaped by distinctive local circumstances (OECD, 2025). This does not establish that regional intervention is necessarily more effective than national policy, nor that the existence of inequality provides sufficient justification for institutional reform. The value of a place-sensitive approach depends upon its capacity to identify the causes of particular difficulties, distinguish between problems requiring different responses and establish whether cooperation across institutions can achieve benefits that existing arrangements do not readily secure.

For DevolvED, the central question is therefore whether the capabilities of educational institutions, public services, enterprises, communities and regional leadership could be brought into a more purposeful relationship around the circumstances that influence opportunity. Such an approach would require a disciplined distinction between weaknesses within individual institutions, barriers arising from wider social and economic conditions, and problems caused or compounded by insufficient coordination between organisations. Some difficulties will require national policy, additional resources or improved institutional practice rather than regional partnership. Others may reveal opportunities for more coherent decisions and investment. The case for a connected regional ecosystem rests upon identifying those opportunities and demonstrating the additional public value that could arise from addressing them.

[POP-OUT BOX 2.1 — THE PROBLEM OF FRAGMENTATION]

An institution can fulfil its responsibilities effectively while the wider system still fails to provide the opportunities that people need. DevolvED seeks to address the space between institutional performance and collective public value.

2.2 Educational Inequality and the Conditions of Opportunity

The persistence of educational inequality provides one of the strongest reasons to examine the wider conditions through which opportunity is created. England possesses institutions of considerable educational quality and a national framework of standards, expectations and accountability, yet differences in attainment and progression remain substantial. These inequalities have consequences beyond the immediate award of qualifications. They can influence access to further education, apprenticeships, higher education, employment and the wider experiences through which individuals develop confidence, knowledge and agency. Their significance for DevolvED lies not in suggesting that educational disadvantage can be resolved through regional governance alone, but in recognising that its causes and consequences frequently extend across institutional and policy boundaries.

The latest manuscript cites provisional Department for Education Key Stage 4 statistics for 2025/26, reporting a difference of 26.8 percentage points between disadvantaged and other pupils achieving grade 5 or above in both English and mathematics. It also reports that the gap, while slightly narrower than in the preceding year, remained wider than in 2018/19 (Department for Education, 2026). [EVIDENCE VERIFICATION — Confirm the provisional 2025/26 release, the precise definition of disadvantage, the reported percentage-point difference and the historical comparison before publication.] Subject to that verification, the evidence illustrates the persistence of educational inequality despite the considerable attention devoted to standards, school improvement and targeted support.

These figures should not be interpreted as demonstrating that institutional fragmentation causes the attainment gap. Educational outcomes arise through complex and interacting influences, including prior learning, teaching quality, attendance, family resources, disability, health, social conditions and the availability of appropriate support. Nor can a national attainment difference establish the effectiveness of any proposed regional intervention. A stronger evidential case would examine variation between places, including differences within regions that may be concealed by regional averages, and would consider the relationship between educational outcomes and the circumstances affecting access to opportunity. The purpose would be to identify where existing approaches are effective, where barriers persist and whether particular difficulties could be addressed more successfully through cooperation.

The importance of educational quality remains fundamental. Strong disciplinary knowledge, effective teaching, reliable assessment, ambitious expectations, attendance and institutional leadership are necessary foundations for improvement. DevolvED does not propose replacing these priorities with a broader programme of social intervention. It argues that they should be considered alongside the conditions through which learners are able to participate successfully. A young person experiencing insecure housing, persistent illness or substantial caring responsibilities may encounter barriers that cannot be resolved through classroom practice alone. Another may possess the qualifications and motivation to progress but lack accessible transport, reliable guidance or sufficient understanding of the opportunities available. In each case, the challenge is not simply whether provision exists, but whether the individual is able to benefit from it.

These relationships are especially significant for learners with special educational needs and disabilities, care-experienced young people and those whose circumstances require support from several services. Schools, colleges, local authorities, health organisations and other providers may each possess legitimate responsibilities, but the learner's experience can depend upon how effectively those responsibilities connect. A regional approach could examine whether existing arrangements provide appropriate continuity, where barriers arise and which organisations possess the authority and capability to address them. Such an examination must preserve statutory duties and individual rights, including responsibilities relating to SEND, safeguarding and children in care. It must also avoid assigning educational institutions responsibility for social conditions they cannot reasonably be expected to resolve.

A more connected regional ecosystem would therefore be concerned with identifying specific circumstances in which educational improvement could be strengthened through complementary action. This might include better alignment between educational provision and transport, improved continuity of specialist support, more accessible information about progression or more effective relationships between learning providers and wider public services. The contribution of cooperation would need to be demonstrated rather than assumed, and the distribution of benefits across different groups and communities would require particular attention.

[FIGURE 2.1 — THE INTERCONNECTED CONDITIONS OF EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITY]

Retain the illustration placeholder. The figure should show educational quality at the centre of a wider set of interacting conditions, including family circumstances, health, housing, transport, financial security, SEND support, guidance and access to wider experiences. It should distinguish factors within the direct responsibility of educational institutions from those requiring complementary action by other organisations.

Central message: improving educational opportunity requires both excellent educational provision and attention to the conditions that enable people to participate and progress.

2.3 The Fragility of Transitions: The 14–25 Experience

The years between 14 and 25 provide a particularly revealing perspective on the relationship between institutional arrangements and individual experience. During this period, young people develop their knowledge and understanding, establish a growing sense of identity, acquire greater independence and make decisions that may shape their future opportunities. Their development is continuous, but the institutions through which they receive education, guidance and support are organised around distinct stages, responsibilities and funding arrangements. These divisions may be administratively necessary and professionally appropriate, yet they do not always correspond to the ways in which young people experience learning, change and progression.

Movement from school into sixth form or further education may involve changes in expectations, teaching environments, financial support, transport and access to specialist services. Progression into apprenticeships, higher education, technical training or employment can introduce further discontinuities, while young people who change direction, return to learning or require additional support may encounter difficulties in identifying appropriate opportunities. For many, these transitions are navigated successfully and represent positive stages in personal development. For others, particularly those experiencing disadvantage, disability, care experience or health difficulties, the boundaries between institutions can become points at which participation weakens, information is lost or support becomes less coherent.

National participation and destination statistics provide an important starting point for understanding these challenges. The latest manuscript refers to Department for Education local-authority statistics for 2025/26 covering participation in education and training among 16- and 17-year-olds, young people identified as not in education, employment or training, and those whose activity is not known (Department for Education, 2026). [EVIDENCE VERIFICATION — Confirm the publication period, definitions and availability of the cited local-authority data. Add selected national and local comparisons where reliable figures are available.] These measures require careful interpretation. In particular, young people known to be NEET must be distinguished from those whose activity has not been established, since differences in tracking completeness can affect apparent comparisons between areas.

The policy challenge extends beyond securing a recorded destination at the end of an educational stage. It concerns the quality and continuity of the opportunities available to young people, the guidance through which they understand their choices, and the support they receive when circumstances change. A young person entering a course that proves unsuitable may need timely information about alternatives; another may require specialist assistance to sustain participation; while a third may benefit from opportunities to explore technical, academic or professional interests before making a major decision. A system concerned with human capability should therefore attend to the experience of progression as well as the administrative measurement of participation.

A regional strategy focused on the whole 14–25 experience could provide a framework through which participating institutions examine these questions together. It might enable schools, academy trusts, colleges, universities, employers, local authorities and relevant services to identify recurring transition difficulties, improve the visibility of available opportunities and strengthen the continuity of appropriate support. It could also examine whether young people have sufficient access to encounters with enterprise, research, professional practice and community life to make informed decisions about their futures. Such cooperation would not require a single regional organisation to control the learner journey, but it could create a more coherent understanding of how different institutional contributions affect that journey.

Any approach involving information about individual learners would require careful attention to lawful data use, safeguarding, confidentiality, statutory responsibilities and professional judgement. The value of more connected information should not be confused with an unrestricted entitlement to share personal records. Equally, a regional approach must not become a mechanism for directing young people towards predetermined local destinations or restricting their freedom to study, work or live elsewhere. The objective is to expand the quality and continuity of opportunity, enabling individuals to make informed choices and pursue aspirations that may extend well beyond their immediate region.

[POP-OUT BOX 2.2 — EVERY TRANSITION MATTERS]

A young person's development is continuous. The institutions supporting that development are not. A more coherent regional approach should seek to reduce the disadvantages created where those boundaries interrupt learning, support or progression.

2.4 Health, Housing and Transport: The Wider Architecture of Participation

Educational opportunity is shaped by circumstances extending well beyond the education system. The relationship between health, employment, income, housing and social conditions is well established in the literature on health inequalities, while the Marmot Review's reassessment of health equity in England demonstrated the continuing significance of these wider determinants and their unequal distribution across communities (Marmot et al., 2020). For DevolvED, the importance of this evidence lies in recognising that participation in learning, employment and civic life may depend upon conditions influenced by several different public responsibilities. Effective educational provision remains essential, but its benefits may be constrained where people encounter barriers that educational institutions cannot independently remove.

Physical and mental wellbeing can influence attendance, concentration, confidence and the capacity to sustain participation. Housing insecurity may disrupt learning, family stability and access to appropriate facilities, while inadequate transport can make otherwise suitable courses or employment opportunities difficult to reach, particularly where specialist provision is geographically dispersed. These circumstances are not confined to young people. Adults seeking to return to education or employment may require childcare, health support, accessible transport or financial advice, while workers responding to technological change may need opportunities for learning compatible with employment and family responsibilities. The wider architecture of participation therefore concerns the practical conditions through which individuals can make use of educational and economic opportunities throughout life.

Public policy frequently addresses these needs through separate programmes and organisations, each operating within legitimate statutory, professional and financial responsibilities. Yet the individual may experience their combined effects as a single set of opportunities or constraints. A person may be offered an appropriate course but lack a reliable means of reaching it; another may receive effective employment guidance while health or caring responsibilities prevent participation; and a family may benefit from educational support whose effects are weakened by persistent housing instability. These circumstances do not imply that one institution should assume responsibility for every difficulty. They demonstrate why the effectiveness of separate interventions may depend partly upon how their contributions are understood and connected.

Transport provides a useful illustration. Investment that improves access to a further education college may generate educational benefits through increased participation or more reliable attendance. Depending upon the circumstances, it may also improve access to employment, widen the opportunities available to families and assist employers in recruiting people with relevant capabilities. Similarly, effective support for young people's mental health may produce benefits extending beyond healthcare, potentially influencing educational participation, family wellbeing and later economic opportunity. These are plausible relationships rather than guaranteed results. Their scale, distribution, costs and causal contribution would require careful evaluation, and the same benefit must not be counted repeatedly under different institutional objectives.

The implication for regional policy is that some investment decisions may be better informed when their consequences are examined across relevant institutional boundaries. Devolved authorities may be well placed to contribute where they possess lawful responsibilities for transport, economic development or related strategic functions, while educational institutions, health organisations and local authorities retain their own responsibilities. The challenge is to establish cooperation that improves the alignment of decisions without obscuring accountability or creating unnecessary bureaucracy. A connected regional ecosystem should therefore be understood not as a single organisation controlling public services, but as a set of purposeful relationships through which their combined contribution to participation and opportunity may be strengthened.

2.5 From Meeting Economic Demand to Creating Regional Opportunity

The relationship between education and regional economic development is frequently expressed through the language of skills requirements, employer demand, workforce participation and productivity. These are indispensable concerns. Regions need effective arrangements for understanding current and emerging occupational requirements, supporting technical education, improving progression and connecting employers with appropriate learning opportunities. A successful regional education proposition must build upon these priorities and recognise the importance of high-quality provision that responds to genuine economic needs. Nevertheless, a strategy concerned exclusively with supplying the capabilities requested by existing industries risks overlooking the contribution of education, research and innovation to the creation of future opportunities.

Economic development is not a static process in which educational institutions simply prepare individuals for an established pattern of employment. New industries, technologies, services and forms of enterprise emerge through interactions between knowledge, research, investment, creativity and practical application. Universities contribute through fundamental and applied research, professional education, independent inquiry and connections with national and international intellectual networks. Further education colleges develop advanced technical capabilities, support adult learning and contribute to the adoption and application of innovation. Schools establish the foundations of knowledge, understanding and intellectual development upon which later opportunities depend. Enterprises bring investment, entrepreneurial activity and practical challenges through which new ideas are tested, while public services and communities can contribute knowledge of unmet needs, opportunities for innovation and perspectives arising from lived experience.

The potential significance of these contributions lies partly in their relationships. Research may reveal scientific or technological possibilities whose practical development requires technical expertise, enterprise investment and supportive infrastructure. Colleges may help organisations adopt unfamiliar technologies or develop the workforce capabilities necessary for innovation to become productive. Public services may identify complex challenges that benefit from interdisciplinary research and new forms of professional practice. Community organisations may help ensure that innovation responds to social needs rather than solely to established commercial demand. Such relationships do not imply that every institution should pursue identical objectives, but they suggest that a region's capacity to create future opportunities may depend upon how effectively its distinctive capabilities are able to interact.

International experience offers useful illustrations of these possibilities. Brainport Eindhoven has developed through sustained relationships between research-intensive universities, applied knowledge institutions, enterprises and regional leadership within an established innovation ecosystem. The Basque Country provides another example of the contribution of technical education, industrial capability and long-term institutional relationships to regional innovation. These experiences should not be treated as directly transferable models. Their governmental arrangements, economic histories, industrial structures and investment patterns differ from those of English regions, and their achievements cannot be attributed solely to institutional cooperation. Their relevance is more specific: they demonstrate how the relationships between knowledge creation, technical capability, enterprise and public leadership can form part of sustained regional development.

INTERNATIONAL INSIGHT | THE NETHERLANDS

Brainport Eindhoven Creating a Regional Future Through Knowledge and Innovation

The Brainport Eindhoven region illustrates how sustained relationships between universities, applied research organisations, technical education, businesses and regional government can contribute to an innovation ecosystem. Its institutions collaborate through research partnerships, shared facilities and programmes connecting knowledge with practical application.

The significance is not simply the supply of skilled workers to existing employers. It is the creation of conditions in which new technologies, enterprises and economic opportunities can develop.

THE LESSON FOR DevolvED Education and research should not merely respond to a region's economic future. They should help create it.

An illustrative comparison, not a model that can be transplanted directly into England.

The lesson is not that England should replicate the Dutch institutional model. It is that regional economic futures can be shaped through sustained relationships between knowledge creation, technical capability, enterprise and public leadership.

For DevolvED, the resulting ambition extends beyond improving the supply of skills to existing employers. It invites regions to consider how educational and research institutions might help identify emerging possibilities, develop new capabilities, strengthen enterprise and contribute to the creation of future industries and services. Universities have a particularly important contribution as independent civic institutions whose value cannot be confined to commercialisation or graduate employment. Through research, teaching, public engagement and critical inquiry, they can help communities understand changing circumstances, challenge policy assumptions and participate in the creation of new regional futures. The role of colleges, schools and other learning providers is equally significant within their respective purposes, connecting knowledge and capability with practical application and widening participation in opportunity.

A more generative relationship between education and prosperity would therefore recognise that regional economic development creates resources and opportunities for learning, while learning, research and innovation contribute to the development of the region itself. This reciprocal relationship does not diminish the importance of meeting current labour-market needs. It places those needs within a wider understanding of how economic futures are formed and how people can contribute to shaping them. Section 4 examines the practical contribution of research, innovation and institutional relationships in greater detail.

2.6 The Public Value Lost Between Institutions

The preceding analysis suggests that some opportunities for improving public outcomes may lie between established institutional responsibilities. This does not mean that institutions should be merged, that their performance should be judged principally through collective measures or that every difficulty arises from inadequate cooperation. Individual organisations retain essential duties and professional standards, and weaknesses within those responsibilities must be addressed directly. Nevertheless, the wider effectiveness of a region may depend upon relationships that conventional organisational performance frameworks do not fully capture.

Potential difficulties include interrupted educational progression, inaccessible opportunities, duplicated activity, fragmented support, insufficient adoption of research and investments whose wider benefits are not realised. The existence, scale and consequences of these difficulties should not be assumed. Some may be substantial, while others may be relatively minor or already addressed through effective local partnerships. A credible regional assessment would therefore begin by establishing where problems actually occur, how they affect individuals and communities, and whether they arise from institutional performance, wider structural conditions or relationships between organisations.

Three questions are particularly important. First, where is there credible evidence of unmet need, unequal opportunity or avoidable inefficiency? Second, to what extent are these problems influenced by relationships between institutions rather than by weaknesses within individual organisations, insufficient resources or broader social and economic circumstances? Third, would stronger regional cooperation provide a proportionate and effective response when compared with alternatives? These questions offer a practical test of the case for a more connected ecosystem. They distinguish the identification of a problem from the diagnosis of its causes, and the diagnosis of its causes from the selection of an institutional response.

[TABLE 2.1 — FROM FRAGMENTED ARRANGEMENTS TO CONNECTED PUBLIC VALUE]

These are propositions for investigation, not claims of benefits already demonstrated by DevolvED.

The table illustrates where cooperation might contribute additional value, but it does not establish that new governance arrangements are necessary. Existing partnerships may already perform some of these functions effectively, while particular problems may be resolved more simply through changes in funding, professional practice, information or institutional decisions. A regional strategy would therefore need to establish its additionality: what would improve because of the proposed relationships, what those improvements would cost, who would possess responsibility for delivery and how their effects could be evaluated. The relevant standard is not the visibility of collaboration, but its contribution to better outcomes and more effective use of public resources.

2.7 Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent: A Timely Opportunity for Investigation

The developing discussions concerning devolution in Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent provide a potentially valuable setting in which to examine these questions. The latest manuscript records a Staffordshire County Council announcement dated 28 October 2026 stating that the Government had agreed to begin discussions about establishing a Mayoral Strategic Authority for Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent, with potential regional influence over transport, skills, housing, employment and economic growth (Staffordshire County Council, 2026). [SOURCE VERIFICATION — Confirm the announcement, its precise wording, the status of discussions and the relevant governmental responsibilities before publication.] Such discussions, if confirmed, would not constitute an agreed settlement or imply endorsement of DevolvED by national government or regional partners. They would, however, provide a timely context in which to consider whether the development of regional governance could be informed by a broader understanding of education, human capability and prosperity.

Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent contain a diverse combination of urban and rural communities, universities, further education colleges, schools and academy trusts, employers, research capabilities and public-service institutions. Their histories, economic circumstances and patterns of accessibility differ considerably, and the opportunities available to people cannot be adequately understood through regional averages alone. A serious assessment would therefore need to examine educational attainment, participation, progression, health, housing, transport, employment and economic opportunity through consistent geographical definitions and appropriate national comparisons. It would also need to recognise the strengths, resilience and ambitions of communities, rather than presenting the region primarily through measures of deprivation or institutional difficulty.

The existing institutional landscape would be an essential starting point. Local authorities, educational providers, employers, health organisations, community partnerships and other bodies already undertake substantial work across education, skills, economic development and public services. DevolvED should not begin by assuming an absence of cooperation or by proposing arrangements that duplicate established activity. Instead, it should investigate where relationships are effective, where difficulties remain and whether a different approach could contribute additional value. The participation and perspectives of institutions and communities would be necessary to establish both the problems worth addressing and the practical feasibility of any response.

Within the wider Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent geography, North Staffordshire — including Stoke-on-Trent, Newcastle-under-Lyme and Staffordshire Moorlands — could offer a narrower initial context for investigating the whole 14–25 experience. Exploratory ideas associated with Every Future Matters and Learning with Purpose could contribute possible approaches relating to educational progression, place-based learning, engagement with research and enterprise, and the development of human capability. These ideas should not be presented as an agreed regional programme or as commitments made by institutions that have not formally participated in their development. They would require discussion, refinement, evidence and appropriate institutional agreement before any practical demonstration could be contemplated.

The significance of Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent lies therefore in their potential suitability for investigation, not in any claim that they already constitute a pilot or that their circumstances are representative of every English region. A bounded regional examination could provide valuable learning about institutional relationships, the interaction of urban and rural conditions, and the feasibility of more connected educational and economic strategies. Its findings would need to be interpreted in the light of the area's particular characteristics. The wider proposition remains national; a potential regional demonstrator would be one means of examining its practical value.

2.8 Discovery as a Test of Additional Public Value

The analysis developed in this section establishes a basis for further investigation, but not for the immediate adoption of a new institutional model. Educational inequalities persist, the conditions influencing opportunity extend across organisational boundaries, and the 14–25 journey involves transitions between institutions with different responsibilities. Education, research, enterprise and public services also possess complementary capabilities that may contribute to the creation of future regional opportunities. These observations provide reasons to examine whether existing relationships could be strengthened, but they do not demonstrate that any particular governance arrangement would produce better outcomes.

The appropriate next step is therefore a jointly scoped Discovery process capable of examining the evidence, identifying a limited number of problems or opportunities that may justify collective action, and assessing the feasibility of possible responses. Such an investigation should consider the experiences of individuals and communities, the effectiveness of existing provision and partnerships, the legal responsibilities and capabilities of participating organisations, the likely costs of cooperation and the potential distribution of benefits. It should also examine alternatives, including improvements achievable through established institutions and agreements without the creation of additional structures.

Potential areas for investigation might include transitions within the 14–25 journey, the accessibility of learning opportunities, the relationship between education and wider public services, and the connections between research, technical capability and enterprise. Each would require a clear account of the problem, the contribution expected from cooperation and the evidence necessary to judge success. Discovery should remain open to the possibility that particular elements of the proposition are unnecessary, impractical or less effective than simpler alternatives. Section 6 develops the design, evaluation and decision gateways through which such an inquiry could be undertaken.

[POP-OUT BOX 2.3 — THE CASE FOR DISCOVERY]

The strongest argument for DevolvED is not that institutions should collaborate more. It is that England should investigate where purposeful collaboration could demonstrably expand opportunity, strengthen regional capability and generate additional public value.

2.9 The Implications for a Regional Education Strategy

The case for a more connected regional ecosystem leads to an important conclusion. If educational opportunity is influenced by wider social and economic circumstances, and if education and research contribute to the future possibilities of regions, then education cannot be understood solely as a service delivered within an otherwise separate regional development strategy. It must also be recognised as one of the foundations through which that strategy is conceived. This does not imply that education should become subordinate to economic policy or that regional leadership should assume control over institutions whose responsibilities remain national, local or independently governed. It implies a more purposeful relationship between educational development, economic opportunity, public-service improvement and the aspirations of communities.

Such a relationship would need to combine educational excellence with a broader understanding of participation and progression. It would recognise the importance of rigorous subject knowledge, effective teaching and established qualifications while considering how learners encounter opportunities beyond their immediate institutions. It would connect the development of technical and professional capabilities with research, enterprise and innovation, without reducing education to the requirements of existing labour markets. It would also recognise that lifelong learning, personal agency and civic participation contribute to the development of both individuals and places. The resulting ambition would be educationally demanding, economically relevant and concerned with the wider purposes of human flourishing.

A Regional Education Strategy could provide one means through which these ambitions are articulated and pursued by willing institutions and relevant public authorities. Its value would depend upon the extent to which it improves understanding, decisions and cooperation without weakening established responsibilities. The next task is therefore to examine what such a strategy might look like when it begins with the whole experience of the learner, recognises the distinctive contributions of schools, colleges, universities and other providers, and connects learning with the knowledge, innovation and opportunities of place.

That is the subject of Section 3.

Publication status — working draft