3. A Regional Education Strategy: Learning with Purpose, Every Future Matters
3.1 Education and the Future of Place
The preceding sections establish that educational opportunity is shaped by relationships extending beyond individual institutions and that the development of human capability contributes directly to the future possibilities of regions. The question now becomes how those principles might inform a more coherent approach to regional education without weakening the national standards, statutory responsibilities and institutional independence upon which the system depends. A Regional Education Strategy could provide one means of addressing that question, bringing together the educational ambitions of a place with the wider circumstances that influence participation, progression, knowledge creation and lifelong learning. Its purpose would not be to establish a separate regional education system, but to make the development of human capability a more deliberate consideration within the decisions that shape regional prosperity.
Such a strategy would need to extend beyond the familiar relationship between education and labour-market demand. Although employer requirements, technical skills and workforce development remain important, a region's educational ambitions cannot be adequately defined by the requirements of its existing industries. The knowledge acquired by learners, the research undertaken by universities, the technical capabilities developed through colleges and the creativity of individuals and communities all contribute to economic and social possibilities that may not yet be visible within current forecasts. A Regional Education Strategy should therefore connect educational excellence and inclusion with the capacity of people and institutions to create new opportunities, recognising that the future of a place is shaped not only by the industries it possesses, but also by the knowledge, capabilities and aspirations it develops.
The strategy would also need to acknowledge that regional educational opportunity is not determined solely by educational institutions. Decisions concerning transport, housing, economic investment, health and public services can influence the accessibility and effectiveness of learning, while educational participation and research can contribute to the achievement of wider regional ambitions. The opportunity is to make these relationships more visible and purposeful, ensuring that regional decisions consider their implications for human capability and that educational institutions have appropriate opportunities to contribute their knowledge and expertise. The value of such an approach would depend upon the additional benefits it creates, rather than the existence of a strategy in itself.
[POP-OUT 3.1 — EDUCATION AS A CREATOR OF FUTURES]
Education should not simply prepare people for the economy a region already possesses. Through knowledge, research, creativity and innovation, it should help people and institutions create the futures that region might achieve.
3.2 From Institutional Provision to a Regional Education Strategy
If education is to occupy a more central position within regional development, the next question concerns the nature of the strategy through which that ambition might be expressed. The answer cannot simply be another document setting out aspirations for improved cooperation. England already possesses a substantial architecture of educational policy, skills planning, institutional partnerships and regional economic development. Any additional strategy must demonstrate how it would complement these arrangements, where it would contribute something distinctive and how its value could be established.
The starting point should be a careful understanding of the educational landscape of the region. This would include the quality and accessibility of existing provision, the experiences of learners, patterns of attainment and progression, the opportunities available through further and higher education, the relationships between education and employment, and the contribution of research and innovation. It would also require consideration of the wider circumstances affecting participation, including health, transport, housing, economic disadvantage and the availability of appropriate support.
Such an assessment should not assume that regional averages provide an adequate description of opportunity. Within a single mayoral geography, communities may experience markedly different circumstances. Urban areas may possess a concentration of educational institutions and employment opportunities while also experiencing persistent deprivation and barriers to participation. Rural communities may face different challenges associated with distance, transport, specialist provision and access to services. The experiences of young people with special educational needs and disabilities, care-experienced learners and those whose education has been interrupted may reveal difficulties that are not apparent in aggregate performance measures.
A credible strategy would need to recognise these differences without allowing the circumstances of particular communities to obscure the importance of common educational entitlements and national standards. The objective would be to understand how the opportunities promised through national policy are experienced in practice, and whether more purposeful regional cooperation could improve their accessibility and effectiveness.
This is where the proposed strategy begins to differ from conventional approaches to educational planning. It would not concentrate solely upon the supply of courses, the distribution of qualifications or the requirements of existing employers. It would consider the relationships between educational opportunity, individual capability and the wider development of the region. It would ask whether young people can move effectively between educational stages, whether adults can return to learning as their circumstances change, whether research and technical expertise are connected with regional opportunities, and whether investment decisions in other policy areas are informed by their consequences for education and participation.
The strategy would therefore be concerned as much with the connections between institutions as with the performance of institutions themselves. This distinction is particularly important because an organisation may fulfil its own responsibilities effectively while the experience of the individual remains fragmented. A school may provide good education, yet a young person may encounter difficulties accessing appropriate post-16 provision. A college may offer excellent technical learning, yet its facilities may be inaccessible to some potential learners. A university may possess research capabilities relevant to regional challenges, yet the relationships needed to connect those capabilities with enterprises, public services or communities may be insufficiently developed.
None of these examples necessarily indicates institutional failure. They illustrate the possibility that additional public value may be created through relationships that lie beyond the direct responsibility of any single organisation.
The development of a Regional Education Strategy would consequently require an approach to governance based upon shared purpose rather than institutional hierarchy. National government would continue to exercise its responsibilities for educational policy, standards, funding and statutory stewardship. Local authorities would retain their duties, including those relating to children and young people, safeguarding and special educational needs and disabilities. Academy trusts, schools, colleges and universities would remain accountable through their established governance and regulatory arrangements. The independence of Ofsted's inspection judgements and the responsibilities of the Office for Students would remain intact.
Within this framework, regional leadership could contribute strategic direction, democratic legitimacy, convening capacity and connections with those responsibilities already exercised through devolved arrangements. A mayoral strategic authority could help ensure that educational considerations inform wider decisions about transport, economic development, housing and investment, without claiming powers over educational institutions that it does not possess.
The principle is straightforward: unity of public purpose does not require uniformity of institutional control.
The practical challenge is to establish arrangements through which different responsibilities can contribute more effectively to shared outcomes. This would require clarity about what participating organisations are being asked to achieve, the decisions they are authorised to make, the resources they can commit and the evidence through which their contributions would be evaluated.
It is for this reason that DevolvED distinguishes between a Regional Education Strategy, a National–Regional Partnership Agreement and a Regional Education and Prosperity Agreement. The strategy would articulate the shared educational ambition. A National–Regional Partnership Agreement, where negotiated and authorised, could clarify relevant commitments between central government and the mayoral strategic authority. A Regional Education and Prosperity Agreement could subsequently express the commitments co-created by participating institutions across the region.
These instruments would be related, but they would not be interchangeable. A national agreement could not unilaterally impose obligations upon independent universities, academy trusts or other organisations. A voluntary regional agreement could not transfer statutory responsibilities or override national regulatory requirements. Most importantly, the substance of a Regional Education and Prosperity Agreement should emerge from Discovery and discussion with prospective partners, rather than being determined in advance.
This approach would give the strategy both ambition and discipline. It would allow regional partners to consider a wider educational future while preserving the responsibilities, independence and professional expertise upon which effective institutions depend.
[TABLE 3.1 — THREE COMPLEMENTARY INSTRUMENTS]
The value of this architecture would depend not upon its complexity but upon its capacity to support decisions and relationships that are demonstrably better than those available through existing arrangements. If Discovery were to establish that established partnerships could achieve the same objectives more effectively, the appropriate response would be to strengthen those partnerships rather than introduce additional machinery.
A Regional Education Strategy should therefore be understood as a proposition to be developed and tested, not a predetermined administrative solution.
3.3 Learning with Purpose: Knowledge, Understanding and the Capacity to Contribute
The phrase Learning with Purpose expresses an important educational principle within the wider DevolvED proposition. It begins with the recognition that education is most valuable when it enables individuals to develop knowledge, understanding and capabilities through which they can make sense of the world, exercise judgement and pursue meaningful possibilities.
Purpose should not be confused with immediate utility. Some of the most important educational experiences have no direct occupational application. The study of literature can develop imagination, interpretation and an understanding of human experience. Mathematics can reveal structures and relationships that are intellectually significant long before their practical applications become apparent. Science enables learners to investigate the natural world and evaluate evidence. History, philosophy, the arts and other disciplines contribute to cultural understanding, critical judgement and the capacity to consider alternative explanations of the world.
These purposes are intrinsic to education. They should not be displaced by the understandable desire to improve employability or respond to changing economic requirements.
At the same time, knowledge can acquire additional significance when learners encounter opportunities to apply, question and extend their understanding through authentic experiences. The intellectual development associated with disciplinary learning need not be separated from the practical challenges encountered in communities, enterprises, research institutions and public services. Properly designed, these relationships can enrich learning while preserving its academic rigour.
Consider a group of young people investigating the energy performance of housing in their community. Such an inquiry could involve scientific understanding of heat transfer, mathematical analysis of energy consumption, consideration of environmental conditions, communication with residents and engagement with technical specialists. The educational value would not arise simply from the authenticity of the challenge. It would depend upon the quality of the knowledge taught, the structure of the learning experience, the opportunities for critical inquiry and the standards against which achievement was assessed.
A similarly rigorous approach could be developed through challenges concerning public health, environmental sustainability, local history, digital innovation, transport, enterprise or the future of community spaces. In each case, the region would become a resource for learning without becoming the limit of educational aspiration.
The distinction is important. Place-based and challenge-based experiences should complement rather than replace the systematic acquisition of disciplinary knowledge. They should provide opportunities for learners to connect ideas, exercise judgement, develop capabilities and encounter the significance of what they are studying. They should not be used to justify weaker curricula, superficial activity or assessment that fails to recognise demanding educational standards.
International thinking provides useful support for this wider conception of education. The OECD Learning Compass 2030 identifies knowledge, skills, attitudes, values, student agency and wellbeing as interconnected dimensions of preparation for an uncertain future (OECD, n.d.). Although it does not prescribe a model for English education, it reflects a growing recognition that the development of capable individuals requires more than the acquisition of qualifications alone.
For DevolvED, the implications extend beyond curriculum design. A region possesses a wealth of educational resources that may not be fully visible within the boundaries of individual institutions. Universities offer access to research, specialist facilities and intellectual expertise. Colleges possess technical capabilities and relationships with industries. Enterprises can contribute practical problems, professional experience and opportunities for innovation. Public services can provide contexts in which scientific, social and technical knowledge is applied. Cultural and voluntary organisations can connect learning with heritage, creativity, citizenship and community life.
A Regional Education Strategy could explore how these resources might become more accessible to learners and educators, particularly where individual institutions would struggle to establish such relationships independently. It could support the development of partnerships through which knowledge and experience flow in both directions. Researchers might encounter questions emerging from schools or communities. Enterprises might engage with the creativity and insights of young people. Teachers and lecturers might gain access to specialist expertise, while institutions of higher education might develop new opportunities for civic engagement and collaborative inquiry.
The objective would not be to require every learner to participate in the same activities or every institution to adopt a common educational model. It would be to expand the range and quality of experiences available, while ensuring that their educational value is established through appropriate professional judgement and evaluation.
This is also where the relationship between learning and regional prosperity becomes more generative. Young people should not be regarded only as future participants in the labour market. With appropriate support, they can become contributors to the knowledge, creativity and innovation through which their communities develop. Their ideas may not always lead to commercially valuable outcomes, nor should that be the measure of their educational worth. But the opportunity to investigate real questions, engage with different forms of expertise and understand the consequences of knowledge can strengthen both personal development and civic participation.
Learning with Purpose should therefore be understood not as an alternative to rigorous education, but as an approach through which the purposes and possibilities of education can be made more visible to learners. Its ambition is to connect the systematic acquisition of knowledge with opportunities for inquiry, judgement, creativity and meaningful application, while recognising that intellectual development possesses value beyond immediate practical outcomes. The region can contribute to this process by making available forms of expertise, experience and authentic challenge that no individual institution could necessarily provide alone. In this sense, Learning with Purpose offers a possible expression of the wider DevolvED proposition: the development of human capability becomes connected with the life and future of place, without subordinating educational standards to regional economic objectives.
[POP-OUT 3.2 — LEARNING WITH PURPOSE]
Learning with Purpose connects rigorous knowledge and understanding with the development of agency, judgement, creativity and the capacity to contribute. It expands the meaning of educational opportunity without compromising educational standards.
3.4 Every Future Matters: A Coherent Journey from 14 to 25 and Beyond
The years between 14 and 25 offer a particularly compelling starting point for examining how a Regional Education Strategy might improve the experience of learners. They encompass a period of exceptional significance in intellectual, personal and social development, during which individuals deepen their knowledge, form identities, encounter new responsibilities and make decisions that may influence the direction of their adult lives.
These years are also characterised by transitions. Young people move between schools, sixth forms, colleges, universities, training providers, employment and other forms of learning. Some follow relatively direct academic pathways. Others pursue technical education, apprenticeships or combinations of learning and work. Some change direction as their interests develop or their circumstances alter. Others encounter difficulties that interrupt their participation and require opportunities to return.
The diversity of these experiences should be understood as a legitimate feature of human development rather than as a series of departures from a preferred institutional route.
Yet the systems supporting young people are frequently organised around the boundaries of individual institutions and funding arrangements rather than the continuity of the learner's experience. Each provider has its own responsibilities, admissions processes, information systems, expectations and support arrangements. These differences are often appropriate and necessary, but they can also create difficulties at precisely those moments when young people are required to make significant decisions.
A learner approaching the end of compulsory education may need to understand the relationship between qualifications, future study, apprenticeships and employment. Another may possess the motivation and capability to pursue a particular course but face barriers associated with transport, cost or the availability of suitable provision. A young person with additional needs may require continuity of support across several institutions and public services. A care-experienced learner may face particular challenges as educational transitions coincide with changes in living arrangements, financial circumstances or personal support.
The quality of an educational system cannot be judged solely by the provision available within each institution if significant numbers of learners encounter avoidable barriers between those institutions.
This is the human significance of Every Future Matters.
The phrase expresses a commitment to the individual: every young person should have access to high-quality learning, appropriate support, meaningful choices and credible opportunities to develop their future. It does not imply that every learner should follow the same pathway or that a region should determine the ambitions of its young people. Rather, it requires institutions and public authorities to consider whether their combined arrangements enable individuals to pursue the possibilities that education should open.
A more coherent regional approach could examine the entire 14–25 journey without assuming that one organisation should become responsible for it. Schools, academy trusts, colleges, universities, employers, local authorities and relevant public services would continue to exercise their own responsibilities. The opportunity would lie in understanding how those responsibilities interact from the perspective of the learner.
This could involve examining the quality of information and guidance, the accessibility of different routes, the continuity of appropriate support and the extent to which educational providers understand the opportunities available through neighbouring institutions. It could also involve investigating patterns of progression, identifying where participation is interrupted and considering whether stronger cooperation might improve outcomes for particular groups.
Such work would require care. The desire to understand the learner journey must not become a justification for indiscriminate collection or sharing of personal information. Safeguarding, data protection, institutional responsibilities and the rights of individuals would need to shape any arrangements. Nor should a regional strategy create additional reporting burdens without demonstrating a clear educational purpose.
The ambition should be to improve the experience of young people, not simply the quantity of information held about them.
The wider significance of the 14–25 journey lies in the relationship between personal development and the opportunities of place. Young people should be able to encounter the educational, cultural, scientific and economic resources of their region while developing aspirations that extend nationally and internationally. They should be able to understand the changing world of employment without being confined to its current requirements. They should have opportunities to engage with research, enterprise and community life without losing the benefits of rigorous academic and technical education.
The region, in this understanding, becomes an environment rich in possibilities rather than a boundary around ambition.
The same principle extends beyond the age of 25. Human development does not conclude with the completion of initial education. Adults may need to acquire new capabilities, change occupations, return to study or respond to changing personal circumstances. Technological development, demographic change and economic restructuring will continue to create demands for learning throughout life. A regional strategy concerned with human flourishing must therefore recognise adult education, professional renewal, community learning and opportunities for later participation as integral to its wider purpose.
The 14–25 journey offers a bounded and practical starting point for Discovery, but it should not define the limits of the ambition.
[FIGURE 3.1 — THE WHOLE LEARNER JOURNEY WITHIN A REGIONAL ECOSYSTEM]
The figure should place the continuous development of the learner at its centre, extending from adolescence into adult life. Schools, further education, higher education, employers, research institutions, public services and communities should appear as interconnected contributors rather than as a predetermined linear sequence. The illustration should distinguish the continuity of individual development from the institutional boundaries through which learning and support are provided.
The significance of this approach is not simply that transitions might become easier, valuable though that would be. It is that a region could begin to understand educational opportunity as a continuing process of capability development, shaped by institutions whose contributions are different but potentially complementary.
In that sense, Every Future Matters becomes more than an expression of concern for young people. It provides a practical test of whether regional institutions are capable of organising their relationships around the needs, aspirations and development of individuals rather than solely around their own administrative boundaries.
3.5 From Shared Ambition to Demonstrable Public Value
The development of a Regional Education Strategy would represent an important statement of ambition, but its significance would ultimately depend upon what it enabled institutions and communities to achieve. A strategy that produced agreement in principle without changing the quality of opportunity would add little public value. Equally, a partnership that generated additional meetings, reporting requirements and administrative complexity without demonstrable benefits could weaken the very institutions it was intended to support.
The next stage must therefore be concerned with disciplined implementation.
The starting point should be Discovery: a structured process through which prospective partners examine the existing educational landscape, identify areas of strength and weakness, consider the experiences of learners and communities, and establish where more purposeful cooperation might make a difference. Such work should be informed by published educational evidence, relevant research, institutional knowledge and the experience of those whose opportunities are affected.
Discovery should not begin with the assumption that a particular institutional model is required. Nor should it treat the existence of separate responsibilities as sufficient evidence of fragmentation. Some boundaries protect essential standards, professional independence and accountability. Some existing partnerships may already be achieving valuable outcomes. The purpose of inquiry would be to distinguish arrangements that work well from those in which opportunities remain unrealised.
This distinction is particularly important when considering the relationship between regional leadership and educational institutions. A mayoral strategic authority may be well placed to connect education with transport, investment, economic development and other regional priorities, but it should not be assumed that these responsibilities confer the authority or expertise required to direct educational provision. The value of regional leadership would lie in establishing conditions for purposeful cooperation, supporting shared priorities and ensuring that educational development is recognised within wider regional decisions.
The institutions themselves would remain responsible for the commitments they were authorised to make. A school or academy trust might contribute through opportunities for progression and collaboration. A college might strengthen technical education and relationships with employers. A university might contribute research, independent evaluation and knowledge exchange. Local authorities and public services might participate where their statutory responsibilities and resources were relevant. Enterprises and community organisations might provide expertise, opportunities and perspectives that enrich the work of educational institutions.
The resulting commitments would need to be specific enough to evaluate. A general ambition to improve progression would require an understanding of the barriers being addressed, the learners affected, the responsibilities of participating organisations and the evidence through which improvement would be judged. A proposal to strengthen relationships between universities and enterprises would need to identify the forms of knowledge exchange or innovation being pursued and the conditions necessary for their success.
This does not mean that every benefit can be reduced to a single numerical indicator. Some important educational and civic outcomes are difficult to measure, and the attribution of change to particular interventions may be uncertain. Nevertheless, the difficulty of evaluation should not become an excuse for avoiding it. Quantitative evidence, qualitative inquiry, comparative analysis and independent assessment can together provide a more credible understanding of what has been achieved.
The strategy should therefore establish a relationship between shared ambition, agreed commitments, practical delivery and learning from evidence. It should remain capable of adaptation as circumstances change and as experience reveals which approaches are effective.
[FIGURE 3.2 — FROM SHARED PURPOSE TO PUBLIC VALUE]
The figure should show a continuous cycle rather than a simple administrative sequence: shared regional purpose informs Discovery; Discovery enables co-created priorities; participating institutions make authorised commitments; implementation generates evidence; evaluation informs adaptation and renewed strategic choices. National standards, institutional accountability and public participation should be represented as continuing safeguards throughout the cycle.
This approach also provides a basis for considering a potential Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent demonstrator. The emerging discussions concerning regional devolution create a possible context in which educational development could be considered alongside wider regional ambitions. North Staffordshire, with its combination of educational institutions, research capabilities, enterprises, urban and rural communities and differing patterns of opportunity, could provide a bounded setting for examining aspects of the 14–25 journey.
Such a demonstrator would not constitute an agreed regional programme, nor would the existence of devolution discussions imply support for DevolvED. Its development would depend upon engagement with prospective partners, evidence of need, the identification of feasible priorities and agreement about responsibilities, resources and evaluation.
The significance of a demonstrator would lie in its capacity to test the national proposition under real institutional conditions. It could reveal opportunities for stronger cooperation, but it might also identify legal, financial, operational or professional constraints that limit what regional arrangements can achieve. Both kinds of finding would be valuable. The purpose of Discovery is to establish what is possible and worthwhile, not to confirm assumptions made in advance.
The larger ambition remains national. Different regions possess different institutional capabilities, economic circumstances, demographic characteristics and histories of collaboration. A successful approach should therefore be capable of adaptation rather than dependent upon the replication of a single model.
What should remain consistent is the underlying purpose: to expand human capability and regional opportunity through stronger relationships between education, knowledge, enterprise, public services and communities.
A Regional Education Strategy would provide a means of bringing that purpose into the decisions through which regional futures are shaped. Learning with Purpose would ensure that educational development retains its intellectual and human significance. Every Future Matters would place the experiences and possibilities of individuals at the centre of the inquiry.
Together, these ideas offer a proposition more ambitious than improved institutional coordination and more substantial than a regional skills plan. They suggest that the development of people should become one of the defining purposes of regional strategy, while the development of place should be understood partly through the opportunities it creates for people to learn, contribute and flourish.
The next section considers the contribution of learning, research and innovation to this ambition. It examines how universities, colleges, enterprises and public institutions can become more effective partners in the creation of knowledge, capability and new regional possibilities, while preserving the independence and distinctive purposes upon which their contributions depend.