4. Learning, Research and Innovation for Regional Transformation
4.1 From Educational Capability to Regional Transformation
A Regional Education Strategy concerned with human flourishing must extend beyond the experiences and progression of individual learners, important though these remain. It must also consider how the knowledge, research capabilities and intellectual resources of educational institutions contribute to the development of the wider region. The relationship between education and prosperity is not confined to the preparation of individuals for existing employment. It encompasses the creation of new knowledge, the development and adoption of technologies, the formation of enterprises, the improvement of public services and the capacity of communities to respond to changing economic and social circumstances. These contributions are not peripheral benefits of educational activity. They form part of the means through which regions develop the capabilities necessary to shape their futures.
The significance of this relationship becomes clearer when regional development is understood as a process of continuing learning and innovation rather than simply the attraction of investment or the expansion of established industries. New economic possibilities emerge through combinations of scientific discovery, technical expertise, entrepreneurial initiative, professional knowledge and institutional cooperation. Universities may generate research that creates opportunities for new products, services or public-policy approaches, while colleges provide technical capabilities that enable organisations to adopt and apply unfamiliar knowledge. Enterprises contribute practical experience, investment and the capacity to bring innovations into use, while public services and communities can identify challenges whose resolution requires expertise extending across institutional boundaries. The resulting relationships are rarely linear. Knowledge may move in several directions, and the value created may be economic, social, cultural or environmental rather than exclusively commercial.
The challenge for regional strategy is therefore not to establish a single institutional mechanism through which innovation should occur, but to understand how the capabilities already present within a region might interact more effectively. Some relationships will develop independently through research partnerships, professional networks, enterprise collaboration and established institutional missions. Others may be constrained by limited awareness, unequal access to expertise, fragmented funding arrangements or the absence of appropriate opportunities for cooperation. Regional leadership could potentially contribute by making these connections more visible, aligning relevant public investments and helping institutions identify shared opportunities that would otherwise remain difficult to pursue. Its role should be enabling rather than directive, respecting the independence of research and education while examining whether more purposeful relationships could generate additional public value.
This understanding also places important limits upon the proposition. Not every research activity should be expected to demonstrate an immediate regional economic return, and not every university or college should be required to organise its work around locally determined priorities. Fundamental research, independent scholarship, cultural inquiry and the pursuit of knowledge for its own sake remain essential to the intellectual vitality of society. Their future significance may be impossible to predict, and their benefits may extend far beyond the region in which they originate. A credible approach to regional transformation must therefore recognise that the most valuable contribution of educational and research institutions may arise precisely because they retain the freedom to question existing assumptions, explore unfamiliar possibilities and develop knowledge whose eventual application cannot be determined in advance.
[POP-OUT 4.1 — FROM SKILLS SUPPLY TO REGIONAL CAPABILITY]
The most important contribution of education and research may not be their ability to supply the capabilities demanded by today's economy, but their capacity to help create the knowledge, industries, institutions and opportunities of tomorrow.
4.2 Universities, Further Education and the Regional Knowledge Ecosystem
Universities occupy a distinctive position within the development of regional capability because their responsibilities extend across advanced education, scholarship, research, professional formation, knowledge exchange and innovation. They generate new knowledge, preserve and challenge established understanding, educate professionals and researchers, and connect local institutions with national and international intellectual communities.
Their contribution to regional development is therefore substantial, but it should not be understood principally through the number of graduates entering local employment or the commercial income generated through research.
Universities contribute to the intellectual and cultural life of society in ways that cannot always be translated into immediate economic outcomes. Fundamental research may produce discoveries whose applications emerge many years later. Scholarship in the humanities and social sciences may deepen understanding of institutions, communities and human behaviour. Professional education contributes to the quality of healthcare, teaching, engineering, law, public administration and other essential activities. Research may challenge established policies, expose weaknesses in conventional assumptions or identify opportunities that existing institutions have failed to recognise.
These contributions depend upon academic freedom, institutional independence and the capacity to pursue knowledge beyond the immediate priorities of government or enterprise.
For DevolvED, this independence is not an obstacle to regional collaboration. It is one of the principal reasons why universities can make a valuable contribution.
A region that seeks only research confirming its existing ambitions will diminish its capacity for learning. A region that welcomes independent inquiry, critical evaluation and intellectual challenge is better placed to recognise mistakes, reconsider priorities and respond to changing circumstances.
The civic university movement has helped develop a broader understanding of the relationship between universities and the places in which they are situated. The work associated with civic university agreements and the UPP Foundation Civic University Commission has encouraged institutions to consider how their educational and research missions contribute to the social, cultural, economic and environmental development of their communities (UPP Foundation Civic University Commission, 2019).
The significance of this approach lies in moving beyond occasional engagement activities towards a more sustained relationship between institutional purpose and civic responsibility.
A university's contribution might include research partnerships addressing regional challenges, professional education supporting public services, opportunities for enterprise and innovation, cultural activity, community participation and the development of evidence to inform public policy. These activities need not conflict with national or international academic ambitions. Indeed, regional questions may provide opportunities for research whose significance extends far beyond the region itself.
A Regional Education Strategy could help connect these contributions with a wider understanding of regional priorities, provided that universities participate as independent partners rather than institutions subject to mayoral academic direction.
The relationship must also be reciprocal. Universities should not be regarded simply as repositories of expertise that regional authorities can draw upon when convenient. Their research and educational development can be enriched through engagement with communities, enterprises and public institutions. Questions emerging from local experience may reveal gaps in existing knowledge, create opportunities for new research and challenge assumptions about the nature of regional problems.
A serious civic relationship therefore involves knowledge moving in both directions.
Further education occupies an equally important, though differently constituted, position within the regional knowledge ecosystem. Colleges are often discussed principally in relation to technical qualifications, apprenticeships and workforce development. These responsibilities are significant, but their contribution extends into advanced technical capability, applied learning, professional renewal, adult education and the practical adoption of new technologies.
Colleges frequently maintain close relationships with smaller enterprises, local communities and individuals whose educational experiences have not followed conventional academic routes. They may possess specialist facilities, technical expertise and practical knowledge of industries that are essential to innovation, particularly where businesses lack the resources to undertake substantial research or development independently.
The contribution of further education to regional transformation should therefore not be regarded as secondary to that of universities. It is different, complementary and frequently indispensable.
A scientific discovery may create the possibility of a new process, but its adoption may require skilled technicians, engineers, production specialists and continuing professional education. The development of advanced manufacturing, digital systems, environmental technologies and modern public services depends upon a range of capabilities extending from research and design through to practical application, maintenance and organisational change.
The relationship between universities and colleges offers particular opportunities in this regard. Research-intensive institutions may generate new knowledge and specialist expertise, while colleges contribute technical development, applied experimentation and connections with enterprises and communities. Stronger relationships could support the translation of knowledge into practice, improve progression between educational pathways and create opportunities for learners to encounter forms of research and innovation that might otherwise remain inaccessible.
Such collaboration would need to recognise differences in institutional missions, funding arrangements and regulatory responsibilities. It should not imply that colleges are simply delivery partners for universities, or that universities should abandon the distinctive purposes of scholarship and research.
The objective is complementarity rather than hierarchy.
Schools and academy trusts also have an important place within this ecosystem. Their principal responsibility remains the provision of high-quality education, but the knowledge, curiosity and intellectual confidence developed during the school years establish foundations upon which later innovation and enterprise depend. Carefully designed relationships with researchers, colleges, universities, employers and cultural organisations can enrich educational experiences, introduce young people to unfamiliar forms of inquiry and broaden their understanding of possible futures.
These opportunities must remain educationally rigorous. Engagement with enterprise or research should deepen knowledge and understanding rather than displace the curriculum or substitute activity for learning. Their value should be established through appropriate educational judgement and evaluation.
The potential contribution of a Regional Education Strategy lies in connecting these different capabilities without attempting to standardise them. Not every university, college or school will possess the same strengths, and not every institution should be expected to participate in every regional initiative. A more productive approach would identify where expertise is complementary, where barriers prevent effective relationships and where cooperation could create educational, economic or public value beyond what institutions could achieve individually.
The resulting knowledge ecosystem would be characterised by diversity of expertise, purposeful relationships and the capacity to connect learning, discovery, application and participation.
[FIGURE 4.1 — THE REGIONAL KNOWLEDGE AND INNOVATION ECOSYSTEM]
The illustration should show the relationships between schools, further education, universities and research institutions, enterprise, public services and communities. Knowledge creation, technical application, innovation and participation should be represented as interconnected activities rather than as a simple hierarchy or one-way pipeline.
4.3 From Research Excellence to Innovation, Enterprise and Public Value
The contribution of research to regional development is frequently associated with scientific discovery, intellectual property, commercialisation and the creation of new enterprises. These activities can generate substantial economic benefits, and regions possessing strong research institutions may be well placed to develop new technologies and industries.
Nevertheless, the relationship between research excellence and regional prosperity is neither automatic nor straightforward.
Knowledge can be generated in one location and applied elsewhere. A university may conduct internationally significant research while local enterprises possess limited capacity to engage with it. A promising technology may remain commercially undeveloped because the investment, technical expertise or organisational capabilities required for its application are unavailable. Public services may be aware of relevant research yet struggle to translate its findings into changes in professional practice.
The challenge is therefore not simply to increase the production of knowledge, but to strengthen the conditions through which knowledge can be understood, developed, adopted and used.
Research and innovation scholarship has long recognised the importance of relationships between universities, industry and government. The triple helix model associated with Etzkowitz and Leydesdorff (2000), for example, highlights the interactions through which these institutions contribute to knowledge-based development. Such models are valuable because they draw attention to the institutional relationships surrounding innovation, although they should not be treated as prescriptions for a particular form of regional governance.
For DevolvED, the implications are practical. Regional transformation depends not only upon the existence of research institutions, but upon the relationships between those institutions, enterprises, investors, technical education, public services and communities.
These relationships may require deliberate development.
Small and medium-sized enterprises are particularly important. While some possess substantial technical and innovative capabilities, others may lack access to specialist knowledge, research facilities, finance or the expertise required to adopt unfamiliar technologies. Universities and colleges can help address some of these difficulties through knowledge exchange, technical support, professional education and collaborative innovation. Yet such opportunities may remain inaccessible if businesses are unaware of the expertise available, cannot afford to participate or lack the organisational capacity to make effective use of it.
A regional strategy could investigate these barriers and examine whether existing innovation and enterprise support arrangements are sufficiently coherent. The objective would not be to create another programme simply because institutions operate separately, but to identify where purposeful cooperation could improve access, adoption and outcomes.
This brings attention to an aspect of innovation that is sometimes overshadowed by the pursuit of new discoveries: diffusion.
The economic and social benefits of innovation depend substantially upon the extent to which useful knowledge and technologies are adopted across organisations. A region may possess a small number of highly innovative enterprises while many other businesses continue to operate with outdated processes, limited technical capabilities or insufficient access to professional development. Improvements in productivity and competitiveness may therefore depend as much upon the wider adoption of existing knowledge as upon the creation of entirely new technologies.
Further education colleges, professional networks, universities and business-support organisations can contribute to this process. Their relationships with employers and communities may help translate advanced knowledge into forms that can be used in different organisational settings.
The same principle applies to public services.
Innovation in healthcare, education, social care, local government and other public institutions may arise through new technologies, but it may also involve changes in professional practice, service design, organisational relationships or the use of evidence. The adoption of research-informed approaches can improve effectiveness and accessibility, although such improvements must be established through appropriate evaluation rather than assumed.
Public-service innovation is especially relevant to DevolvED because it connects the development of knowledge with the wider conditions of human flourishing. Research concerning health inequalities, educational participation, environmental quality or community wellbeing may inform interventions whose value extends beyond commercial activity.
Universities can contribute independent inquiry and evaluation. Colleges may support the development of professional and technical capabilities. Public services can provide practical settings in which ideas are tested, while communities contribute knowledge of lived experience and the consequences of proposed changes.
These relationships can strengthen the quality of innovation by ensuring that technical possibilities are considered alongside human needs, professional responsibilities and the realities of implementation.
They also require safeguards. The involvement of public services in research and innovation must respect statutory duties, professional standards, confidentiality and the rights of individuals. New technologies should not be adopted merely because they promise efficiency or attract investment. Their effectiveness, risks, costs and distributional consequences require careful examination.
A regional innovation strategy concerned with public value would therefore ask not only whether new knowledge has been generated, but whether its application improves the opportunities and experiences of people.
This provides a more demanding understanding of regional transformation. It recognises the importance of research excellence and enterprise while acknowledging that their wider contribution depends upon adoption, institutional capability and the distribution of benefits.
[POP-OUT 4.2 — THE INNOVATION CHALLENGE]
Discovery creates possibilities. Innovation develops them. Adoption determines whether their benefits reach enterprises, public services and communities.
4.4 International Experience and the Development of Regional Innovation Ecosystems
International experience offers useful perspectives on the relationships between education, research, enterprise and regional development. It also demonstrates the importance of understanding the particular institutional and historical circumstances through which successful regional ecosystems emerge.
Brainport Eindhoven provides one illustration. The region has developed a substantial concentration of technological expertise, advanced manufacturing, research institutions and enterprises, supported by long-standing relationships between public authorities, knowledge institutions and industry. Its development is associated with institutions including Eindhoven University of Technology, applied research organisations and major technology enterprises, alongside a wider network of specialist suppliers and smaller businesses.
The significance of Brainport lies not simply in the presence of internationally competitive firms. It is also found in the relationships through which research, technical expertise, investment and enterprise have developed over time. These relationships have contributed to an environment in which knowledge creation and industrial capability reinforce one another.
Yet Brainport should not be presented as evidence that institutional collaboration alone produces regional prosperity. Its development reflects a particular industrial history, substantial technological capabilities, long-term investment and national as well as regional conditions. The lesson for England is therefore not that the Dutch model can be replicated through the establishment of a partnership board or a regional agreement.
It is that the development of a knowledge-intensive regional economy requires sustained attention to the relationships between research, technical capability, enterprise, investment and public leadership.
The Basque Country provides a different but equally instructive perspective. Its experience of industrial restructuring and the development of regional innovation capabilities illustrates the potential significance of long-term institutional commitment, technical education, applied research and relationships between government and enterprise. The region's technology centres, vocational education institutions and industrial networks form part of a wider system through which economic capabilities have been developed and renewed.
Again, the institutional circumstances differ from those of England. The Basque Country possesses forms of governmental authority and a history of industrial policy that cannot simply be transferred into an English mayoral settlement. Its experience is nevertheless relevant because it demonstrates that technical education and applied knowledge can occupy central positions within regional transformation rather than being treated as subordinate elements of a university-led innovation system.
Singapore offers a further perspective, particularly through its emphasis upon continuing education, workforce development and the adaptation of human capability to economic change. Initiatives associated with SkillsFuture illustrate the importance of lifelong learning and the relationships between educational institutions, employers and national economic priorities.
Singapore is a city-state with institutional and governmental characteristics substantially different from those of English regions. Its experience should therefore be interpreted as an illustration of sustained national commitment to capability development, not as a directly transferable governance model.
Taken together, these examples support several conclusions.
First, regional innovation ecosystems are developed over time. They cannot be created simply through the announcement of a strategy or the establishment of a new institutional structure.
Second, their effectiveness depends upon complementary capabilities. Research excellence matters, but so do technical education, investment, enterprise, professional development and the capacity to adopt new knowledge.
Third, public leadership can contribute by establishing direction, supporting relationships and creating conditions for long-term investment, but it cannot substitute for the expertise, initiative and independence of the institutions involved.
Finally, successful arrangements are shaped by place. Their development reflects particular histories, economic structures, institutions and opportunities. This reinforces the importance of Discovery within DevolvED. Regions should begin by understanding their existing capabilities and relationships rather than assuming that a successful international example provides a ready-made model.
The value of international experience lies in expanding the range of possibilities considered, while strengthening the discipline with which those possibilities are evaluated.
[INTERNATIONAL INSIGHT — THE LESSON FROM BRAINPORT AND THE BASQUE COUNTRY]
Regional innovation is not created by institutional proximity alone. It develops through sustained relationships between knowledge, technical capability, enterprise, investment and public leadership, shaped by the distinctive circumstances of place.
4.5 Creating the Conditions for Regional Transformation
The argument developed in this section suggests that a Regional Education Strategy could contribute to economic and social transformation by strengthening the relationships through which knowledge becomes capability, innovation and public value. Yet the creation of such relationships requires more than a general commitment to partnership.
A region seeking to develop its knowledge ecosystem would first need to understand the capabilities it already possesses.
This would involve examining the research strengths of universities, the technical expertise and facilities available through further education, the innovative capacities of enterprises, the requirements and opportunities of public services, and the contributions of community and cultural institutions. It would also require attention to the networks connecting these organisations, the barriers affecting participation and the availability of investment, infrastructure and professional expertise.
Such an assessment should be sufficiently broad to recognise capabilities that may not be immediately visible through conventional economic analysis. Research in the humanities and social sciences may contribute to understanding public policy, social behaviour and cultural development. Community organisations may possess detailed knowledge of unmet needs and opportunities for service improvement. Smaller enterprises may demonstrate innovative practices that are not captured adequately by measures of formal research and development.
The purpose would be to identify where existing strengths could be developed, where complementary capabilities might be connected and where significant barriers prevent knowledge from becoming useful opportunity.
This is also where regional leadership could make a distinctive contribution. A mayoral strategic authority, acting within its lawful responsibilities, may be able to connect economic development, transport, infrastructure, investment and skills priorities with a wider understanding of the region's educational and research capabilities. It could convene institutions, support shared analysis and help identify opportunities for cooperation that cross existing policy boundaries.
But its role should be enabling rather than directive.
Universities must retain the freedom to pursue research and education according to their academic missions. Colleges must be able to respond to their learners, communities and employers within their governance and funding arrangements. Enterprises must retain commercial independence, while public services remain accountable for their statutory responsibilities and professional standards.
The opportunity lies in developing a shared understanding of regional possibilities and identifying where institutions are willing and able to make complementary commitments.
These commitments might concern access to specialist facilities, opportunities for collaborative research, technical education, knowledge exchange, professional development or the testing of innovations in appropriate settings. Some may be achievable through existing institutional relationships. Others may require additional resources, agreements or changes in the way established programmes are coordinated.
Discovery would need to determine which opportunities justify action.
The evaluation of such activity should extend beyond counting partnerships, research projects or participants. These measures may be useful indicators of activity, but they do not establish the additional value created. A stronger approach would consider whether cooperation has improved access to expertise, supported the development or adoption of innovation, strengthened institutional capability, expanded educational opportunity or generated identifiable benefits for enterprises, public services and communities.
Where possible, evaluation should distinguish between outcomes attributable to the intervention and changes that might have occurred anyway. It should also consider who benefits, who may be excluded and whether the distribution of opportunities is consistent with the wider ambition of human flourishing.
This is particularly important where regional innovation strategies concentrate upon sectors or institutions that already possess substantial advantages. Investment in areas of existing strength may be economically justified, but a strategy concerned with inclusive prosperity must also consider how the benefits of development reach communities with fewer established opportunities.
The aim should not be to distribute every investment equally or to require every institution to perform the same functions. It should be to establish a defensible relationship between the development of regional capability and the expansion of opportunity across the population.
[FIGURE 4.2 — FROM KNOWLEDGE TO REGIONAL PUBLIC VALUE]
The illustration should show knowledge creation, technical development, enterprise and public-service innovation, adoption and diffusion, and the resulting economic, social and civic outcomes. Feedback relationships should demonstrate how experience and evaluation generate new research questions, educational requirements and opportunities for innovation.
A Regional Education Strategy could provide an important framework for this work because it would connect the development of knowledge and capability with the wider ambitions of people and place. It would not replace economic development policy, research funding arrangements or institutional strategies. Rather, it could help ensure that the relationships between them are considered deliberately, and that opportunities for additional public value are not lost through avoidable separation.
The potential significance extends beyond any individual demonstrator.
If DevolvED is to make a contribution to the next phase of English devolution, it must offer a way of thinking about regional development that recognises education and research as creative forces rather than supporting services. It must acknowledge the distinctive contributions of universities, colleges, schools, enterprises, public institutions and communities, while providing a credible basis for cooperation that respects their responsibilities and independence.
Above all, it must connect the development of regional capability with the opportunities available to people.
The future of a region is not determined solely by the industries it possesses, the infrastructure it builds or the investment it attracts. It is also shaped by the knowledge its institutions generate, the capabilities its people develop, the innovations its organisations adopt and the purposes towards which those resources are directed.
A region capable of learning, researching, innovating and adapting is better placed to create new possibilities for prosperity. A region that connects those possibilities with the development of its people is better placed to turn prosperity into public value.
This is the deeper contribution that learning, research and innovation could make to DevolvED. They provide not simply instruments of economic growth, but foundations for a more capable, creative and flourishing society.
4.6 International Perspectives: Learning from Regions That Have Transformed Their Futures
The proposition advanced in DevolvED is ambitious, but it does not arise in an international vacuum. Across different countries, governments, educational institutions, research organisations and enterprises have developed forms of cooperation through which learning, knowledge and innovation contribute to economic renewal and wider social development. Their experiences offer valuable insights into the conditions that enable regional transformation, the institutional relationships required to sustain it and the difficulties involved in translating shared ambition into demonstrable public value.
Three examples are particularly instructive: Brainport Eindhoven in the Netherlands, the Basque Country in Spain and Singapore. They differ substantially in scale, political authority, economic history and institutional arrangements. Brainport represents a regionally organised knowledge and technology ecosystem; the Basque Country illustrates the integration of technical education, applied innovation and industrial development; and Singapore demonstrates a sustained national commitment to lifelong learning and the renewal of human capability.
These examples should not be treated as models that can simply be imported into England. Their relevance lies in understanding the mechanisms through which education, research, enterprise and public leadership have become mutually reinforcing, and in identifying which of those mechanisms might be adapted within England's constitutional and institutional circumstances.
Brainport Eindhoven: Building a Regional Knowledge and Innovation Ecosystem
<text color="secondary" italic>International case study 1 — The Netherlands</text>
The development of Brainport Eindhoven offers an especially relevant perspective on the relationship between regional economic transformation, knowledge institutions and public leadership. Located in the southern Netherlands, the region has become internationally recognised for its concentration of advanced technology, research, design and high-value manufacturing. Its development is closely associated with a long industrial history, including the presence of Philips and the emergence of technology enterprises and specialist supply chains that have subsequently contributed to its economic character.
The significance of Brainport, however, lies in more than the success of individual companies. It is the deliberate cultivation of relationships between enterprises, universities, vocational education institutions, research organisations and public authorities that makes the region particularly interesting for DevolvED.
The Brainport Foundation and Brainport Development provide an institutional focus for regional cooperation. Their activities connect public authorities, knowledge institutions and industry around shared ambitions for innovation, talent development and the conditions necessary to sustain regional prosperity. This is not a system in which a single public authority directs the educational or commercial activities of participating institutions. Rather, it reflects a continuing process of strategic cooperation through which organisations with distinct responsibilities identify shared interests and develop complementary action.
Eindhoven University of Technology contributes advanced scientific and technological research, while Fontys University of Applied Sciences and vocational institutions such as Summa and Ter AA connect higher professional education, technical learning and practical application. These institutions operate within a wider environment that includes research organisations, major enterprises, smaller specialist businesses and facilities supporting technological development.
The relationships are not merely conceptual. At Brainport Industries Campus, educational institutions work alongside industry in environments intended to connect technical learning with contemporary manufacturing technologies and professional practice. Such arrangements create opportunities for learners to encounter advanced production methods while enabling enterprises to engage with educational and research expertise.
In June 2026, for example, Fontys and Summa renewed a longstanding agreement for shared laboratory facilities at the Nexus building on the Eindhoven University of Technology campus. Their collaboration supports vocational and higher professional education, with an explicit interest in progression between educational levels and the development of lifelong learning opportunities (Summa, 2026).
This is a particularly important illustration for DevolvED. The boundaries between educational institutions do not disappear, and their qualifications, governance arrangements and academic missions remain distinct. Nevertheless, shared facilities and sustained cooperation can create opportunities that would be difficult for individual institutions to provide independently.
The regional approach also extends to the transitions experienced by young people. In March 2026, Brainport Development described a joint initiative involving Summa, Ter AA, Fontys and Eindhoven University of Technology to improve the transition from secondary education into vocational and higher education. The stated intention was to connect and strengthen existing initiatives rather than establish an entirely new educational system (Brainport Eindhoven, 2026a).
There is an obvious parallel with the thinking developed in Section 3. A coherent learner journey does not necessarily require the creation of a single institution or the transfer of control from one provider to another. It may instead depend upon institutions taking collective responsibility for the quality of transitions, the visibility of opportunities and the continuity of learning.
Perhaps the most directly relevant feature of Brainport is its experience of negotiated national–regional investment.
The Brainport Eindhoven Regional Deal, operating between 2018 and 2025, brought together the Dutch national government, the Province of North Brabant and regional partners. According to the completion report published in August 2026, the participating authorities and regional organisations jointly invested €479 million across 26 projects concerned with innovation, talent development and regional facilities (Brainport Eindhoven, 2026b).
The breadth of this programme is significant. Its activities included technological innovation and opportunities for practical learning, but also cultural, sporting and community facilities. The underlying proposition was that a successful knowledge-intensive economy depends not only upon research excellence and skilled employment, but also upon the quality of the place in which people live.
This is a much richer understanding of regional competitiveness than one concerned exclusively with industrial output or the supply of technical labour. Housing, accessibility, cultural life, community facilities and opportunities for participation affect a region's capacity to attract and retain people, but they also matter intrinsically to the quality of life available to existing residents.
Brainport's experience therefore reinforces the reciprocal relationship between people and place at the centre of DevolvED.
It also illustrates the potential value of an agreement between national government and a region that connects investment with a coherent understanding of regional development. The relevance to the proposed National–Regional Partnership Agreement is substantial, although the Dutch arrangements operate within different governmental structures and should not be interpreted as an exact institutional precedent.
Brainport nevertheless presents important questions as well as achievements. Its concentration of advanced technology and internationally competitive enterprises creates pressures associated with housing, transport, infrastructure and access to opportunity. The benefits of growth are not necessarily distributed equally, while the demand for highly specialised labour can create dependencies upon national and international recruitment.
These pressures demonstrate why successful economic development cannot be regarded as sufficient evidence of inclusive regional prosperity. The capacity of a region to generate wealth must be considered alongside its ability to provide affordable living conditions, accessible public services and meaningful opportunities for its wider population.
Nor can Brainport's economic achievements be attributed simply to its partnership structures. Its development reflects decades of industrial specialisation, accumulated knowledge, investment and institutional relationships. The regional agreements and organisations are part of that history rather than a complete explanation of it.
The lesson for DevolvED is therefore not that establishing a regional partnership will reproduce Brainport's success. It is that sustained cooperation between education, research, enterprise and public leadership can provide a framework through which existing strengths are developed, new capabilities are created and national investment is connected to regional purpose.
Brainport demonstrates the value of connecting economic ambition, educational continuity, innovation and quality of place within a sustained national–regional partnership.
The Basque Country: Technical Education, Industrial Renewal and Regional Transformation
The Basque Country provides a different perspective on regional transformation, rooted in industrial renewal and the development of advanced technical capability. Its experience is particularly valuable because it challenges the tendency to associate knowledge-based development principally with universities and research-intensive enterprises.
The region has a substantial industrial history, including manufacturing, engineering and specialist production. Its economic development has involved the adaptation of established industries, the development of new technologies and sustained attention to the capabilities required by enterprises and workers.
Within this process, vocational education and training has acquired a strategic significance that extends beyond the preparation of individuals for existing occupations.
The Basque vocational education system is closely connected to industrial development, applied innovation and relationships with employers. Its institutions contribute to the development of technical knowledge and professional capability, while also supporting the adoption of new processes and technologies.
A particularly important organisation is Tknika, the Basque Centre for Applied Innovation in Vocational Training. Established under the auspices of the Basque Government's education authorities, Tknika was designed to strengthen relationships between vocational education institutions, enterprises, technology centres and university research departments.
Its purpose is not simply to ensure that vocational curricula respond to changes already occurring within industry. It seeks to make applied research and innovation integral to vocational education itself.
This distinction is central to the argument developed in Section 4. Technical education becomes a contributor to the creation and diffusion of knowledge, rather than a mechanism for transferring established occupational skills from one generation to another.
Tknika works through networks involving vocational teachers, educational institutions and enterprises. Its activities include applied innovation, the development of new learning approaches, the introduction of emerging technologies, support for entrepreneurship and the transfer of knowledge into vocational education and business practice (Tknika, n.d.).
The OECD has identified Tknika as an important intermediary between vocational institutions, research organisations and Basque enterprises, particularly smaller businesses that may lack independent access to specialist innovation resources (OECD, 2020).
The significance of this intermediary role should not be underestimated. Innovation frequently fails to spread because the organisations capable of using new knowledge do not possess the expertise, facilities or relationships necessary to adopt it. A small manufacturing enterprise may understand the potential of a new production technology but lack the capacity to evaluate its application. A vocational college may possess technical expertise but have limited opportunities to engage with advanced research. A university may generate useful knowledge without established routes through which smaller enterprises can benefit from it.
Tknika provides one institutional response to these problems by connecting educational capability with practical innovation.
Its approach also recognises the importance of teachers. The capacity of vocational institutions to support technological development depends upon educators having opportunities to understand emerging technologies, participate in applied projects and renew their professional expertise. Innovation in the economy and innovation in education are therefore treated as related processes.
This has implications extending beyond technical qualifications. Where teachers and institutions participate in the development of new knowledge, learners can encounter contemporary practices and technologies rather than rely exclusively upon established curricula. Educational institutions become more responsive to change because they are themselves involved in exploring it.
The wider Basque approach has also involved coordination between vocational education, employment policy and industrial strategy. The OECD's examination of the region's future-of-work challenges described a vocational education system possessing strong relationships with enterprises and innovation policy, while recognising the continuing need to improve participation in adult learning and the adoption of advanced practices across smaller businesses (OECD, 2020).
This balance between achievement and continuing challenge is important. The existence of a sophisticated vocational system does not eliminate inequalities in opportunity or guarantee that all enterprises benefit equally from innovation. The OECD identified differences in access to workplace training between smaller and larger firms, illustrating the difficulty of ensuring that capability development reaches the whole economy.
The Basque Country also possesses forms of political and fiscal autonomy that differ substantially from those available to English mayoral strategic authorities. Its institutional arrangements reflect a particular history of regional government, industrial development and public policy. They cannot be transferred wholesale into England without consideration of constitutional responsibilities, funding and institutional independence.
Nevertheless, the underlying principles are highly relevant.
First, further education and technical institutions can be active contributors to innovation and economic development, not merely recipients of knowledge generated elsewhere.
Second, the diffusion of technology and professional expertise requires institutions capable of connecting research, education and enterprise.
Third, teachers and technical professionals are themselves essential participants in innovation, requiring opportunities for continuing development and engagement with emerging knowledge.
Finally, regional economic strategy can benefit from recognising vocational education as part of the infrastructure through which industries adapt and new capabilities emerge.
For DevolvED, these lessons strengthen the case for placing further education at the centre of a Regional Education Strategy. Colleges should not be included simply because they supply qualifications required by employers. They possess the potential to contribute to applied research, technical experimentation, enterprise development and the wider renewal of regional capability.
The Basque experience demonstrates that technical education can be part of a region's innovation infrastructure, connecting emerging knowledge with practical capability and industrial renewal.
Singapore: Lifelong Learning and the Continuous Development of Human Capability
Singapore provides a contrasting international perspective. Unlike Brainport Eindhoven or the Basque Country, it is a sovereign city-state rather than a region operating within a larger national constitutional framework. Its institutions, administrative capacity and economic circumstances therefore differ markedly from those of English regions.
Nevertheless, Singapore offers important insights into the relationship between education, economic development and lifelong capability.
Its approach recognises that education cannot be understood as a process largely completed before entry into employment. Technological change, economic restructuring and longer working lives create continuing requirements for individuals to renew their knowledge, develop new capabilities and adapt to unfamiliar circumstances.
SkillsFuture, launched in 2015, provides an institutional framework through which Singapore has sought to strengthen lifelong learning and connect individual development with the changing requirements of enterprises and the economy.
Its activities include support for adult education, professional development, career transitions, workplace learning and the recognition of capabilities developed through experience. The approach involves educational institutions, employers, training providers and public agencies, with policy attention directed towards both individual participation and the capacity of enterprises to make productive use of new skills.
The significance of SkillsFuture is not simply that public resources are available for training. Its wider ambition is to establish continuing learning as a normal and necessary feature of economic and personal development.
This represents a shift from a predominantly sequential understanding of education, in which formal learning is followed by employment, towards a more continuous relationship between learning, work and changing opportunity.
The programme has achieved substantial participation. SkillsFuture Singapore reported that 555,000 individuals participated in supported training during 2024, compared with 520,000 in 2023. The number of employers sending employees for supported training also increased, from 23,000 to 24,000 (SkillsFuture Singapore, 2025).
These figures demonstrate the scale of activity, although participation alone cannot establish the effectiveness of training or its contribution to economic performance. Questions of relevance, quality, progression, access and longer-term outcomes remain essential.
Singapore's approach is also notable for the attention given to employers. The development of individual capability is not sufficient if organisations fail to create opportunities in which that capability can be used. Employers influence whether learning translates into improved professional practice, career progression, innovation and productivity.
This reinforces a central argument of DevolvED: capability is developed through relationships between individuals and institutions. The benefits of education depend partly upon the opportunities available to apply knowledge and upon the willingness of organisations to adapt.
SkillsFuture also provides an important reminder that educational opportunity must extend beyond the initial stages of adulthood.
The 14–25 journey developed in Section 3 offers a purposeful initial focus for regional Discovery because transitions during those years are especially significant. Yet the wider proposition of DevolvED is concerned with human capability across the life course.
Individuals may need to retrain following industrial change, return to education after periods of caring responsibility, develop new capabilities during later working life or pursue learning for personal and civic purposes unrelated to immediate employment.
A regional education ecosystem should therefore be capable of supporting continuing participation rather than treating the completion of an initial qualification as the end of its responsibility.
Singapore's experience also illustrates the importance of sustained public commitment. Lifelong learning cannot be established solely through occasional initiatives or exhortations to individuals to acquire new skills. It requires accessible opportunities, credible provision, financial support, relationships with employers and mechanisms through which learning can be recognised and applied.
The transferability of Singapore's approach must nevertheless be considered carefully. Its centralised governmental arrangements enable forms of policy coordination that cannot be assumed within English devolution. Its economic structure, public institutions and capacity for national programme delivery differ significantly from those of individual English regions.
Nor should a lifelong learning strategy be reduced to the constant adjustment of individuals to labour-market demands. Learning contributes to human flourishing through cultural participation, personal development, civic engagement and the capacity to understand and shape society. These purposes are particularly important within DevolvED, where economic development is understood as one dimension of a wider public ambition.
The lesson from Singapore is therefore not that England should replicate SkillsFuture through a regional training scheme. It is that sustained investment in lifelong capability, supported by institutions and employers, can become a central component of long-term development strategy.
Singapore demonstrates that the development of human capability is a continuing public responsibility, extending beyond initial education and requiring sustained relationships between learners, institutions, employers and government.
What These Experiences Mean for DevolvED
The three international examples offer different perspectives on the development of people and place. Their institutional structures are not interchangeable, and their achievements cannot be attributed to a single policy or governance mechanism. Nevertheless, several common themes emerge.
Each demonstrates the importance of treating education and knowledge as active contributors to economic and social development. In Brainport, the relationships between research, technical education and enterprise contribute to the development of a knowledge-intensive regional economy. In the Basque Country, vocational education participates directly in applied innovation and industrial renewal. In Singapore, lifelong learning is treated as a continuing element of economic adaptability and individual capability.
Each also illustrates the importance of institutions capable of connecting activities that would otherwise remain separated. Knowledge must be translated into application; educational opportunities must be connected across transitions; and individuals must have opportunities to use and develop their capabilities.
These processes require sustained relationships, not simply formal declarations of partnership.
The international examples also reinforce the importance of public leadership. Governments can help establish direction, provide resources, support institutions and create conditions in which cooperation becomes possible. But public leadership does not eliminate the need for institutional expertise, enterprise initiative or independent evaluation.
For England, the relevant question is how these principles might be developed within existing statutory responsibilities, national regulatory arrangements and institutional freedoms.
A mayoral strategic authority could potentially provide a convening and strategic role, connecting economic development, infrastructure and regional priorities with the capabilities of educational and research institutions. A Regional Education Strategy could establish a shared understanding of educational and knowledge-related ambitions. A negotiated National–Regional Partnership Agreement could identify commitments requiring cooperation between central and regional government. A Regional Education and Prosperity Agreement, developed voluntarily with participating institutions following Discovery, could provide a framework for practical cooperation and accountability.
These instruments would serve different purposes. None should be assumed to confer authority that does not exist in law, and none should substitute for the statutory responsibilities or independence of participating institutions.
The international evidence also suggests that a successful regional strategy must attend to the quality of place as well as economic performance. Housing, transport, public services, cultural participation and community life influence whether individuals can benefit from educational and economic opportunities. The development of advanced industries may create substantial prosperity while also generating new inequalities or pressures upon local infrastructure.
A strategy concerned with human flourishing must therefore consider not only how regional capability is created, but how its benefits are distributed.
This is where Discovery becomes especially important. Rather than assuming that the structures developed elsewhere should be reproduced, an English region should investigate its own institutional capabilities, economic opportunities, educational transitions, innovation networks and barriers to participation.
The purpose would be to identify which relationships already work, where additional cooperation could create value and what evidence would be needed to justify new commitments or investment.
The international comparisons do not prove that DevolvED will succeed. They do, however, demonstrate that the relationships upon which it is founded are neither speculative nor without practical precedent. They show that knowledge, technical capability, institutional cooperation and sustained public leadership can become significant elements of long-term development.
The challenge for England is to translate these insights into arrangements appropriate to its own institutions and places.
[FIGURE 4.3 — INTERNATIONAL LESSONS FOR DevolvED: THREE EXPERIENCES, ONE SHARED PRINCIPLE]
The proposed illustration should compare Brainport Eindhoven, the Basque Country and Singapore, identifying their distinctive institutional contributions and the common principles of knowledge development, cooperation, lifelong capability and public value. It should make clear that these are sources of learning rather than models for direct replication.
The wider conclusion is consistent with the central argument of this paper.
The development of people strengthens the possibilities of place; the development of place expands the possibilities available to people.
Brainport illustrates how this relationship may be developed through a regional knowledge and innovation ecosystem. The Basque Country demonstrates how technical education and applied research can contribute to industrial renewal. Singapore shows why the development of human capability must continue throughout working and civic life.
Together, they suggest that the next phase of English devolution should be concerned not only with the allocation of powers or the coordination of services, but with the development of institutions and relationships through which regions become more capable of shaping their own futures.
That ambition requires a careful relationship between national stewardship, regional leadership and institutional independence.
It is to this question that Section 5 now turns.
4.7 International Perspectives — Implications for England
The international experiences considered here do not establish a single model for regional transformation, nor do they demonstrate that institutional cooperation alone produces economic renewal. Their circumstances differ significantly, and their outcomes reflect combinations of historical development, investment, industrial capability, public policy and institutional commitment that cannot readily be separated. Nevertheless, they reveal the importance of relationships through which education, research, enterprise and public leadership contribute to the continuing development of regional capability. Brainport Eindhoven illustrates the potential significance of sustained knowledge-intensive cooperation; the Basque Country demonstrates the contribution of technical education and applied innovation to industrial development; and Singapore provides a perspective on the continuing renewal of human capability through lifelong learning.
For England, the central lesson is not that these arrangements should be replicated, but that the relationships between knowledge, institutions and economic development deserve more deliberate attention within the emerging devolution settlement. The potential contribution of regional leadership would lie in strengthening the conditions through which distinctive institutional capabilities can interact, while preserving the national frameworks, professional responsibilities and independence upon which their value depends. Such cooperation would need to be judged by the additional opportunities, innovation and public value it creates, rather than by the number of partnerships established or strategies agreed. The relevance of these international experiences therefore lies in the questions they invite England to investigate: how knowledge becomes accessible, how technical capability supports innovation, how institutions sustain long-term cooperation and how the resulting benefits can contribute to the flourishing of people and places.
The next question is how national stewardship, regional democratic leadership and institutional independence might be brought into a coherent relationship capable of supporting that ambition.
That is the subject of Section 5.