DEVELOPMENT PREVIEW · Proposition 2.5 and supporting visuals are still being edited · Not for public launch
DevolvED
Proposition 2.5 · Chapter 5 of 7

National stewardship, regional leadership and REPA

Working chapter preview. Text, illustrations, pop-outs and references remain subject to final editorial review.

5. National Stewardship and Regional Collaboration

5.1 A New Relationship Between National Government and the Regions

The preceding sections have established the potential contribution of education, research and institutional cooperation to the development of human capability and regional prosperity. The question now is whether England's existing arrangements for public governance provide sufficient means of connecting these contributions, and how a more purposeful relationship might be established without weakening the responsibilities and freedoms upon which educational quality, institutional effectiveness and public accountability depend. This is not principally a question of transferring authority from one tier of government to another. It concerns the relationship between different forms of legitimate authority, the circumstances in which collective action may be justified and the means through which participating institutions can pursue shared purposes while remaining accountable for their own decisions.

The complexity of this challenge is particularly evident within education. National government retains substantial responsibilities for standards, funding, qualifications and system stewardship, while local authorities discharge important statutory duties and educational providers operate through different legal and governance arrangements. Academy trusts remain accountable for the schools they govern; further education colleges possess their own institutional responsibilities; and universities operate within a framework that recognises academic freedom and institutional autonomy. The development of mayoral strategic authorities adds another important form of democratic leadership, particularly in relation to economic development, infrastructure and relevant devolved functions, but does not automatically resolve the relationships between these different institutions.

The proposition advanced in DevolvED is that a more coherent relationship could be developed through negotiated governmental responsibilities, shared regional educational ambition and voluntary institutional commitment. Such an approach would need to distinguish carefully between the authority to make decisions, the capacity to influence outcomes and the willingness of organisations to cooperate. Its success would depend not upon establishing uniform institutional control, but upon demonstrating that clearer relationships between existing responsibilities can create additional public value.

5.2 National Stewardship: Protecting Entitlement, Standards and Equity

National government has an indispensable role in securing educational entitlement, maintaining standards and protecting the interests of learners. National curriculum and qualification frameworks, arrangements for inspection and regulation, funding systems and statutory safeguards establish expectations that should not depend upon the resources, geography or political priorities of individual regions.

These functions are especially important where differences in local circumstances might otherwise produce inequalities in educational quality, access or protection.

A credible model of regionalisation must therefore begin by identifying the responsibilities that should remain nationally determined, rather than treating central government as an obstacle to regional ambition.

The Department for Education would remain the principal national steward of the education system, exercising its existing responsibilities for policy, institutional oversight and relevant statutory functions. Its regional leadership would continue to discharge responsibilities delegated by the Secretary of State, including engagement with schools, academy trusts, local authorities and improvement arrangements within its remit.

The proposed Regional Education Strategy would not displace these responsibilities. It would provide an additional means through which the Department could understand how national educational objectives interact with regional circumstances, and how the capabilities of institutions and public services might contribute to their achievement.

The distinction is important. National expectations for educational quality should not be diluted because a region adopts different strategic priorities. Nor should participation in a regional agreement alter the statutory basis of inspection, intervention or institutional accountability.

A region could, however, identify circumstances that make the achievement of national expectations more difficult. These might include poor transport connections, fragmented transitions between providers, shortages of specialist provision, limited access to technical facilities or weak relationships between education and employment opportunities. Addressing such barriers may require action by organisations whose responsibilities extend beyond education itself.

The role of regional collaboration would be to make these interdependencies visible and develop appropriate responses, not to substitute regional judgement for national standards.

Other government departments would also have important responsibilities. National policies concerning employment, research, innovation, housing, health, transport and local government shape the circumstances in which learning takes place. HM Treasury's fiscal frameworks and decisions about public expenditure influence the feasibility of longer-term investment, while national research and innovation funding arrangements affect the development of regional knowledge capabilities.

The precise organisation of departments and agencies may change, but the underlying problem remains. Policies developed through separate national portfolios frequently intersect in the lives of individuals and within particular places.

A young person's progression into further education may depend upon transport policy as well as educational provision. The capacity of a region to develop new industries may depend upon research investment, technical education, housing and infrastructure. The participation of an adult returning to learning may be affected by employment, caring responsibilities, health and the availability of flexible provision.

No single government department can fully address these relationships through its own programmes.

A national–regional partnership could provide a structured means of identifying where national decisions intersect, where existing arrangements create avoidable barriers and where greater coordination might improve outcomes. Such cooperation would not remove ministerial accountability or permit regional partners to disregard statutory requirements. It would, however, create opportunities for national policy to become more responsive to evidence about the interaction of services and institutions within particular places.

This would require both ambition and discipline. Regions would need to demonstrate that proposals are evidence-informed, deliverable and consistent with national responsibilities. Government departments would need to be willing to examine whether existing rules, funding arrangements or administrative practices inhibit collaboration without producing corresponding public benefit.

National stewardship and regional initiative should therefore be understood as complementary responsibilities. The purpose of national stewardship is not simply to preserve uniform arrangements, but to secure common entitlements and public confidence while enabling institutions and places to develop the capabilities necessary to achieve them.

[POP-OUT 5.1 — NATIONAL STANDARDS, REGIONAL POSSIBILITY]

National government should protect the entitlement of every learner. Regional leadership should help create the conditions through which that entitlement becomes a meaningful opportunity.

5.3 Regional Democratic Leadership and the Responsibilities of Place

The development of mayoral strategic authorities creates opportunities to consider how democratic regional leadership might contribute more directly to education and human capability. Mayors possess, or may acquire through lawful devolution arrangements, responsibilities concerning aspects of economic development, transport, investment, infrastructure and adult skills. These responsibilities influence educational opportunity even where the mayor does not possess direct authority over schools, colleges or universities.

This creates a legitimate role for regional leadership, but its nature must be carefully defined.

An elected mayor should not be presumed to possess authority over school standards, academy trust governance, university academic decisions or statutory responsibilities retained by local authorities. Nor should regional democratic legitimacy be interpreted as a mandate to direct independent institutions beyond the powers conferred by law.

The opportunity is instead to establish a form of strategic leadership concerned with the conditions in which education, learning and regional prosperity develop.

A mayoral authority may be able to identify how transport arrangements affect access to education, how investment decisions influence the location of employment and training opportunities, or how economic development priorities could be connected with research and technical education. It may also be able to convene institutions around challenges that cannot readily be resolved within a single organisational boundary.

These are substantial contributions, even where the authority does not directly control educational provision.

The proposed Regional Education Strategy would give this role greater coherence. It would establish a shared understanding of the region's educational ambitions and the relationship between those ambitions and its wider economic, social and civic development.

Such a strategy should not be regarded as the mayor's education plan in the conventional sense. It would require the participation of institutions and public bodies with their own responsibilities, alongside employers, communities and learners. Its legitimacy would depend upon the quality of the evidence informing it, the openness of its development and the extent to which participating organisations recognise their own purposes within its ambitions.

Regional leadership would therefore involve persuasion, convening, negotiation and the alignment of relevant powers and resources, rather than the assumption of comprehensive institutional control.

This is not a weak form of leadership. In a complex public system, the ability to connect independent institutions around clearly defined outcomes may be more valuable than possessing formal authority over a narrower range of functions.

The relationship between mayoral authorities and local government is especially important. Local authorities retain responsibilities affecting children's services, safeguarding, special educational needs and disabilities, education-related functions and the wider welfare of children and families. Their knowledge of communities, statutory obligations and relationships with schools and public services make them indispensable participants in any serious regional education strategy.

Where a mayoral geography encompasses several local authorities, differences in local circumstances may be substantial. A regional approach must therefore recognise both the value of coordination across boundaries and the continuing importance of locally accountable services.

It should not replace detailed knowledge of communities with an excessively aggregated regional perspective.

The development of regional strategy would also need to recognise that some institutions operate beyond the boundaries of a single mayoral authority. Multi-academy trusts may serve schools across several areas, universities may recruit nationally and internationally, and colleges may serve economic and travel-to-learn areas that do not correspond neatly to administrative boundaries.

Participation should therefore be determined by relevant responsibilities, relationships and opportunities for contribution rather than geography alone.

The democratic contribution of the mayor would lie in helping to articulate a shared regional ambition, making visible the consequences of strategic decisions for educational opportunity and accounting publicly for the actions and resources within the authority's control.

The significance of regional democratic leadership would therefore lie not simply in its capacity to bring institutions together, but in its ability to connect shared educational ambition with decisions for which it possesses legitimate authority and public accountability. A regional strategy could inform the development of transport, infrastructure, economic investment and relevant skills policies, while participating educational institutions contribute their expertise through their own governance arrangements. This distinction between authority and influence is fundamental. A mayoral authority may be able to create conditions that strengthen educational opportunity without directing educational provision itself, and the credibility of the proposed settlement would depend upon making those responsibilities explicit rather than obscuring them within a general language of partnership.

This would give greater substance to regional accountability without creating confusion about the responsibilities of other institutions.

5.4 Three Complementary Instruments for Regional Education and Prosperity

The institutional architecture proposed by DevolvED rests upon three complementary instruments. Their distinction is essential if the proposition is to move from an attractive aspiration to a credible framework for public policy.

The first is the Regional Education Strategy.

This would articulate the region's shared ambitions for educational excellence, inclusion, progression, lifelong learning, research, innovation and human development. It would consider how these ambitions relate to wider regional priorities, including economic development, transport, health, community wellbeing and the creation of opportunity.

Its purpose would be strategic rather than regulatory. It would identify where greater coherence might improve outcomes, establish priorities supported by evidence and provide a common direction for participating institutions and public bodies.

The second is the National–Regional Partnership Agreement.

This would establish a negotiated relationship between central government and the relevant mayoral strategic authority, with the participation of other departments or public bodies where appropriate. Its purpose would be to identify the governmental commitments, resources, decision-making arrangements and accountability mechanisms required to support agreed regional priorities.

The agreement could recognise existing powers and responsibilities, establish arrangements for cooperation and identify matters requiring national decisions. It could not, merely by being signed, confer statutory powers, redirect funding without authority or alter legal duties.

The third is the Regional Education and Prosperity Agreement (REPA).

REPA would provide a separate framework for voluntary collaboration among participating regional institutions and partners. Schools, academy trusts, further education colleges, universities, employers, local authorities, research organisations, public services and community bodies could contribute to shared ambitions through commitments appropriate to their missions and responsibilities.

Crucially, REPA would not be assumed to exist at the outset. Its detailed form, priorities and commitments would be developed with participating organisations following Discovery. Institutions would need appropriate authority to enter into commitments, and participation could not bind organisations that had not agreed to take part.

This distinction between strategy, governmental agreement and institutional partnership is more than a matter of terminology.

The Regional Education Strategy would establish the shared ambition. The National–Regional Partnership Agreement would identify how national and regional government could support that ambition within their lawful powers. REPA would establish the voluntary commitments through which regional institutions and partners could contribute to its realisation.

Each instrument would serve a different purpose, and none should be mistaken for the others.

Table 5.1 — Proposed architecture for regional education and prosperity

These three instruments should not be understood as successive levels of authority within a single regional education system. The Regional Education Strategy would articulate shared ambition; the National–Regional Partnership Agreement would establish the commitments and responsibilities of the governmental parties; and REPA would provide a separately authorised basis for cooperation among willing institutions. Each would have a different source of legitimacy and a different relationship with existing statutory and institutional responsibilities. Their potential strength would lie in complementarity rather than hierarchy. No agreement between government and a mayoral authority could, by itself, commit an independent educational institution to obligations it had not accepted, and no voluntary regional partnership could override the legal responsibilities of its participants.

The potential value of this architecture lies in connecting ambition with responsibility.

A regional strategy might identify improved access to post-16 education as a priority. The mayoral authority might possess transport or investment functions relevant to that ambition. National government might control funding or policy decisions affecting provision. Colleges, schools, universities and other providers would remain responsible for the educational activities they deliver.

A credible arrangement would identify what each participant could contribute and where the desired outcome depended upon cooperation.

Without such clarity, partnership risks becoming a language of shared aspiration without corresponding responsibility. With it, regional cooperation could become a disciplined means of addressing problems that individual institutions cannot resolve alone.

[FIGURE 5.1 — THE THREE-INSTRUMENT ARCHITECTURE OF DevolvED]

An illustration showing the Regional Education Strategy as the shared direction, supported by two distinct but complementary agreements: the National–Regional Partnership Agreement between governments and REPA among participating regional institutions. National standards, statutory responsibilities and institutional independence should be shown as continuing safeguards.

5.5 Institutional Independence and Differentiated Accountability

The success of a regional education partnership would depend upon the willingness of institutions to contribute to shared ambitions. That willingness cannot be sustained if participation creates uncertainty about governance, professional responsibilities or institutional independence.

Universities offer a particularly important example. Their contributions to regional development may include research, professional education, innovation, civic engagement and independent evaluation. These activities can be aligned with regional ambitions where institutions consider such cooperation appropriate. Nevertheless, universities must remain free to determine their academic priorities, protect academic freedom and discharge their responsibilities under the relevant regulatory framework.

Their independence is not simply a constraint upon regional strategy. It is a source of public value.

A university capable of questioning regional assumptions, producing independent evidence and pursuing knowledge beyond immediate economic priorities can strengthen the intellectual quality of regional decision-making.

Further education colleges similarly possess distinct governance, funding and accountability arrangements. They may contribute substantially to technical innovation, lifelong learning, employer engagement and educational progression, but regional participation should not obscure the responsibilities of their governing bodies or the requirements attached to public funding.

Academy trusts and other school governing bodies also retain responsibilities that cannot be displaced through regional partnership. Trust boards remain accountable for the governance and performance of their academies, including educational quality, safeguarding, financial stewardship and compliance with applicable requirements. Local governing bodies exercise responsibilities according to the arrangements established by their trusts, rather than through an assumed regional mandate.

A Regional Education Strategy could nevertheless create valuable opportunities for cooperation between trusts and other institutions. Shared challenges concerning attendance, inclusion, progression, specialist provision or the development of educational opportunity may justify collaboration across institutional boundaries.

The important distinction is between cooperating on a shared challenge and transferring accountability for an institution's performance.

Local authorities likewise retain their statutory responsibilities. Regional collaboration could help identify cross-boundary pressures, coordinate relevant support or strengthen relationships between services, but it could not relieve an authority of its legal obligations.

The same principle applies to public services, research organisations and enterprises. Each participant would need to understand what it was being asked to contribute, what authority it possessed to make that commitment and how its responsibilities would be discharged.

The governing principle is shared strategic purpose with differentiated accountability.

Institutions may work towards common regional outcomes without becoming subject to a common governing body. National and regional leaders may share ambitions without possessing identical powers. Public reporting may examine collective progress while still identifying which organisations are responsible for particular decisions and activities.

This approach would require care in the language of partnership. Terms such as collective responsibility or shared accountability can be useful, but they may become misleading if they obscure who possesses legal authority, who controls resources or who is answerable when an agreed action is not delivered.

A credible REPA would therefore need to distinguish between common ambitions, individual commitments and outcomes that depend upon several contributions.

That distinction would protect institutional independence while making cooperation more meaningful.

5.6 Making Accountability Work in Practice

The practical test of any proposed settlement is whether responsibility becomes clearer rather than more diffuse.

A coherent accountability framework would distinguish between responsibility for decisions, responsibility for delivery and responsibility for collective outcomes. These dimensions are related, but they are not identical.

A government department may determine a funding framework. An institution may deliver provision within that framework. A mayoral authority may influence the transport, infrastructure or economic conditions affecting participation. Where the desired outcome depends upon all three, effective governance requires more than a general declaration that partners are jointly responsible.

It requires clarity about the decisions each organisation can make, the commitments it has accepted and the evidence through which its contribution will be assessed.

The proposed agreements should therefore establish explicit schedules of responsibility for each agreed priority. These would identify the organisations leading particular activities, the supporting partners, the relevant statutory responsibilities, the resources available and the arrangements for reporting and review.

They should also identify where progress depends upon decisions outside the partnership's direct control, including national funding, regulatory approval or the independent decisions of participating institutions.

This would help address two familiar weaknesses of partnership governance: the diffusion of responsibility when outcomes are disappointing and the inappropriate claiming of collective achievements by individual organisations.

Table 5.2 — Illustrative framework for differentiated accountability

These responsibilities are illustrative and would require validation against the actual powers and duties of participating organisations before being included in any agreement.

The effectiveness of accountability would also depend upon the quality of evidence.

Educational and regional outcomes often develop over long periods. Changes in participation, attainment, research capability, enterprise development or economic opportunity may not become visible within a single financial year or electoral cycle. A regional strategy would therefore require both shorter-term measures of delivery and longer-term indicators of progress.

The evaluation framework should distinguish activity from impact. The establishment of a partnership, the publication of a strategy or the delivery of a programme does not, in itself, demonstrate additional public value.

Evidence should examine whether cooperation has improved outcomes beyond what would reasonably have been expected without it. Where causal attribution is difficult, evaluation should make the limits of the evidence explicit rather than claiming that every positive regional trend results from partnership activity.

This would require an independent evaluative contribution, potentially drawing upon universities and other research organisations, with appropriate safeguards for objectivity.

Public reporting should be accessible and intelligible. Citizens should be able to understand what the regional partnership is attempting to achieve, which organisations have accepted responsibilities, what resources have been committed and what progress has been demonstrated.

The purpose of accountability would not be to create another elaborate reporting system. It would be to strengthen public confidence that shared ambitions are connected to real decisions, deliverable commitments and independently examinable outcomes.

[POP-OUT 5.2 — ACCOUNTABILITY MUST FOLLOW AUTHORITY]

No institution should be held accountable for powers it does not possess. No partner should claim credit for outcomes without demonstrating its contribution. Shared ambition requires clarity of responsibility.

5.7 Funding, Decision-Making and the Limits of Partnership

The effectiveness of any national–regional agreement would depend partly upon its relationship with public finance.

Regional strategies may identify compelling opportunities for cooperation, but their implementation can be constrained where funding streams are narrowly specified, operate over different periods or require institutions to pursue objectives that are not fully aligned.

These difficulties do not necessarily justify the immediate pooling or devolution of budgets. They do, however, suggest that serious Discovery should examine whether existing funding arrangements support the proposed priorities and whether greater flexibility, alignment or coordination could produce additional public value.

The financial responsibilities of participating organisations would need to remain explicit.

A partnership agreement should not imply that resources controlled by one body become available to others without the necessary authority, approval or contractual arrangements. Nor should a regional strategy commit institutions to expenditure they have not agreed or cannot lawfully undertake.

Some opportunities may be achievable through better coordination of existing programmes. Others may require negotiated changes to funding arrangements, additional investment or formal agreements between responsible organisations.

The distinction matters because the language of partnership can sometimes conceal a lack of delivery capacity. Organisations may agree upon desirable outcomes while lacking the authority, resources or institutional incentives necessary to achieve them.

A credible national–regional relationship would need to confront these constraints openly.

It would also need to recognise the different time horizons associated with educational and economic development. The benefits of research investment, technical capability, institutional cooperation or improvements in educational progression may emerge over many years. Short-term funding arrangements and annual reporting cycles can create difficulties where sustained investment is necessary.

This does not remove the need for financial discipline. On the contrary, long-term commitments require clear milestones, proportionate evaluation and opportunities to reconsider approaches that are not producing the intended results.

The purpose of the proposed agreements would therefore be to connect strategic ambition with realistic commitments, not to create expectations that existing institutions cannot fulfil.

This also establishes an important limit to voluntary partnership.

Cooperation cannot resolve every disagreement between institutions, eliminate competition for resources or overcome statutory constraints. Where a proposal requires a change in law, national policy or funding authority, that requirement should be identified explicitly. Where institutions disagree about priorities, the disagreement should be acknowledged rather than obscured by a general statement of consensus.

A mature partnership should be capable of recognising both the value and the limits of cooperation.

The test is whether it creates sufficient additional public value to justify the time, resources and institutional attention required.

5.8 Towards a More Coherent Settlement for People and Place

The institutional architecture proposed in DevolvED offers a possible means of connecting national educational stewardship, regional democratic leadership and the distinctive contributions of independent institutions. Its value would depend upon the clarity of the responsibilities it establishes, the willingness and capability of organisations to participate, and the additional opportunities created through their cooperation. The proposed Regional Education Strategy, National–Regional Partnership Agreement and Regional Education and Prosperity Agreement should therefore be understood as complementary possibilities for examination, not as arrangements whose necessity or effectiveness has already been established.

The central challenge is to determine whether these instruments would enable better decisions and more effective relationships than existing arrangements, while protecting educational standards, institutional independence, statutory responsibilities and public accountability. That judgement cannot be made through institutional design alone. It requires evidence about the problems to be addressed, the resources available, the alternatives that might be pursued and the outcomes that could reasonably be expected. The next stage of the proposition must therefore move from institutional possibility to disciplined investigation, establishing whether a more coherent settlement could create public value sufficient to justify its development.

Publication status — working draft