6. From Ambition to Evidence: Discovery, Demonstration and National Learning
6.1 The Responsibility to Test Ambition
The institutional possibilities examined in the preceding section are sufficiently significant to warrant serious consideration, but their practical value cannot be established through the coherence of the argument alone. A proposal to develop new relationships between national government, regional democratic leadership and independent institutions must demonstrate that it addresses identifiable problems, respects existing responsibilities and offers benefits that could not reasonably be achieved through less complex arrangements. The appropriate response to the ambition of DevolvED is therefore neither immediate implementation nor rejection on the grounds of institutional difficulty, but a disciplined programme of investigation through which its assumptions can be tested and its potential value assessed.
Discovery should be understood as a substantive phase of public-policy development, not as consultation undertaken to secure agreement with a predetermined model. Its purpose would be to establish the educational, social and economic circumstances that justify collective attention; examine the effectiveness and limitations of existing institutional relationships; assess the legal, financial and operational feasibility of the proposed arrangements; and determine whether there is a credible case for further development. The process would need to be open to alternative explanations and different institutional solutions, including the possibility that existing partnerships, funding arrangements or governance mechanisms could achieve the desired outcomes more effectively.
This approach reflects a responsibility to use public resources carefully and to respect the autonomy and legitimate interests of potential participants. Institutions should not be asked to commit themselves to arrangements whose purposes, costs or responsibilities remain uncertain, while national and regional government should not be expected to endorse changes whose additional public value has not been established. Discovery would provide the opportunity to develop a shared evidence base, identify the conditions necessary for effective cooperation and determine whether a limited demonstration could be justified. Its credibility would depend upon the possibility of reaching a negative conclusion as well as a positive one.
6.2 Designing a Regional Discovery Programme
The starting point for Discovery should be an examination of the region as it is, rather than an assumption about the institutions or programmes it ought to possess.
This would involve developing a sufficiently comprehensive understanding of educational opportunity, economic and social circumstances, institutional capability and the relationships connecting them. It would require evidence about attainment, participation, progression, destinations, exclusion, disadvantage and access to education, considered alongside wider factors such as health, transport, housing, employment and the availability of specialist provision.
The purpose would not be to assemble a large statistical portrait for its own sake. It would be to understand where opportunities are being created, where they are being constrained and which problems might be addressed more effectively through cooperation.
Particular attention should be given to the experiences of individuals moving between institutions and stages of learning. Administrative systems often provide detailed information about activity within organisations while offering a less complete understanding of the journeys experienced by learners. A young person may move between school, college, employment, training and higher education, encountering different eligibility arrangements, information systems, support services and institutional expectations. Each organisation may discharge its own responsibilities adequately while the overall experience remains fragmented.
The 14–25 journey offers a useful focus for examining these relationships, although Discovery should also consider adult learning and the continuing development of capability throughout life.
Learners and residents should not be treated merely as consultees whose views are sought after institutional priorities have been established. Their experiences can illuminate barriers that administrative structures or aggregate data may not reveal, particularly concerning transport, access to specialist provision, transitions, confidence, health, financial circumstances and the availability of appropriate guidance.
Meaningful engagement would need to be inclusive, accessible and clear about how contributions would influence subsequent decisions. It should also avoid assuming that young people or communities speak with a single voice.
A second important task would be to understand the region's institutional and intellectual capabilities. Universities, colleges, schools, research organisations, enterprises, public services and community bodies possess different forms of expertise and different relationships with the populations they serve. Discovery should identify the strengths already present, the opportunities for complementary activity and the barriers preventing knowledge and resources from being used effectively.
This inquiry should include the region's capacity for research, technical innovation, enterprise development and professional learning. It should examine how institutions interact with smaller businesses, how public services engage with research, whether specialist facilities are accessible and where opportunities for innovation are limited by organisational or financial constraints.
The international experience considered in Section 4 provides useful questions for this work, but not a predetermined model. Brainport Eindhoven suggests the value of examining sustained relationships between research, technical education, enterprise and public leadership. The Basque Country draws attention to further education as a contributor to applied innovation. Singapore highlights the importance of continuing learning and the capacity of employers to support the application of new knowledge.
The relevant question is not how these arrangements might be copied, but whether comparable relationships could generate value within the region's own circumstances.
A further task would be to map existing partnerships, strategies and governance arrangements. Local Skills Improvement Plans, institutional strategies, local authority plans, regional economic programmes and research collaborations already provide mechanisms through which organisations pursue shared objectives. Discovery should identify which arrangements are effective, where they overlap and where significant gaps remain.
The proposed Regional Education Strategy and associated agreements would be justified only if they provide a clearer or more effective means of addressing issues that existing arrangements do not adequately resolve.
Table 6.1 — Proposed Discovery workstreams
Discovery would require an agreed scope, timetable and proportionate resources, but its precise duration should be determined by the complexity of the questions and the readiness of potential partners rather than by an arbitrary deadline.
An initial phase might establish whether there is a sufficient case for more detailed design. The development of legally robust agreements, institutional commitments and credible evaluation arrangements could require further work.
The essential requirement is that each stage should produce evidence capable of informing a genuine decision.
[POP-OUT 6.1 — THE PURPOSE OF DISCOVERY]
Discovery should not ask how we implement DevolvED. It should ask whether, where and under what conditions DevolvED would create value that existing arrangements cannot.
6.3 Testing the Institutional Architecture
One of the principal questions for Discovery would concern the institutional architecture through which DevolvED might operate.
Section 5 proposed three complementary instruments: a Regional Education Strategy, a National–Regional Partnership Agreement and a Regional Education and Prosperity Agreement. Their distinction is fundamental. They would serve different purposes, involve different participants and require different forms of authority and accountability.
The Regional Education Strategy would provide the substantive direction. It would articulate the region's ambitions for educational excellence, inclusion, progression, lifelong learning, research, innovation and human development, together with their relationship to wider regional prosperity.
Its development would require genuine engagement with educational institutions, local authorities, enterprises, public services, communities and learners. The strategy would need to establish a limited number of priorities that command sufficient support and possess a credible basis for action.
The National–Regional Partnership Agreement would establish a different relationship. It would concern the commitments that central government and the relevant mayoral strategic authority were authorised and willing to undertake in support of agreed priorities.
Its development would require clarity about statutory powers, funding responsibilities, decision-making arrangements and the processes through which matters requiring ministerial or departmental consideration would be addressed. Where educational responsibilities remain with the Secretary of State or other national bodies, those boundaries would need to be recognised explicitly.
The agreement could provide a basis for cooperation, but it could not itself confer powers requiring legislation or other lawful authorisation.
The Regional Education and Prosperity Agreement, or REPA, would serve a separate purpose. It would be developed among regional partners, potentially including the mayoral strategic authority, local authorities, academy trusts, schools, further and higher education institutions, employers, research organisations, health bodies and voluntary or community organisations.
REPA would establish how participating organisations intend to contribute to shared regional ambitions. It could identify practical priorities, institutional commitments, responsibilities, resources and evaluation arrangements.
Its legitimacy would depend upon the informed participation and agreement of the organisations concerned, not upon an assumption that the mayoral authority possesses command over independent institutions.
It would be premature to draft REPA as a completed agreement before Discovery has established which organisations wish to participate, which priorities justify cooperation and what commitments are feasible. Its detailed form should be co-created with those partners following Discovery.
The task during Discovery would therefore be to examine the potential value of each instrument and the relationships between them.
This would involve asking whether a Regional Education Strategy adds clarity beyond existing plans, whether a National–Regional Partnership Agreement could improve cooperation between government and regional leadership, and whether a separate REPA would help institutions undertake practical action that would otherwise be difficult to organise.
It would also require consideration of administrative burden. If the proposed arrangements merely reproduce existing committees, strategies or reporting requirements, they would risk weakening rather than strengthening the system.
A successful architecture would be proportionate, intelligible and capable of supporting decisions.
The three instruments should therefore be regarded as propositions to be tested, not institutional structures whose adoption is assumed in advance.
6.4 Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent as a Potential Demonstrator
The developing devolution context in Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent offers a possible setting in which to investigate the DevolvED proposition, subject to the willingness of the relevant national, regional and institutional partners to participate. The geography combines urban and rural communities, different patterns of educational provision, universities, further education colleges, schools and academy trusts, research capabilities, enterprises and public services. This diversity could provide a useful basis for examining whether stronger relationships between education, regional development and public institutions would generate additional value, while also testing the difficulties of establishing shared priorities across places with different circumstances and needs.
Within the wider geography, North Staffordshire could provide a more focused context for examining the coherence of the 14–25 journey, including educational transitions, purposeful learning and access to opportunities extending beyond individual institutions. Exploratory work associated with Every Future Matters and Learning with Purpose could inform the questions considered during Discovery, but would not constitute an agreed delivery programme or evidence of institutional endorsement. The selection of any demonstrator would need to follow an assessment of regional need, partner commitment, legal and financial feasibility, and the potential to generate findings of wider national significance.
6.5 From Discovery to Demonstration
If Discovery establishes a credible case for proceeding, the next stage would be to design a limited programme of demonstration.
This should not begin with an extensive portfolio of projects intended to showcase every dimension of DevolvED. A more disciplined approach would select a small number of priorities where the potential benefits of national–regional coordination and regional institutional collaboration are substantial, the responsibilities of participants can be clearly identified and outcomes can be evaluated with reasonable confidence.
Possible areas might include improving the coherence and accessibility of the 14–25 journey, developing carefully structured Learning with Purpose experiences, connecting further and higher education research capabilities with regional enterprises, strengthening lifelong learning or addressing cross-sector barriers to educational participation.
These are illustrative possibilities rather than predetermined projects.
The selection process should be informed by the regional evidence base, the priorities identified by partners, the feasibility of implementation and the availability of suitable evaluation methods. It should also consider whether a proposed activity genuinely requires the new partnership architecture or could be delivered equally effectively through existing arrangements.
Each demonstrator would need a clear statement of purpose, an identified lead organisation, the necessary authorisations, agreed resources, a defined population or setting, appropriate safeguards and a credible evaluation design.
The demonstration programme should also distinguish between two questions that are easily confused.
The first concerns whether a particular intervention produces beneficial outcomes. For example, an initiative intended to improve transitions between educational institutions might be assessed through measures of participation, progression, learner experience and sustained destinations.
The second concerns whether the proposed governance architecture adds value. Did the Regional Education Strategy help identify a priority that would otherwise have been neglected? Did the National–Regional Partnership Agreement enable a necessary governmental decision or resource alignment? Did REPA allow institutions to undertake practical commitments that existing arrangements would not have supported?
Positive results from an individual project would not, by themselves, demonstrate the value of the wider institutional model.
Conversely, a partnership might improve strategic understanding and institutional relationships while a particular intervention fails to achieve its intended outcomes. Such findings would need to be examined separately.
This distinction is essential if demonstration is to produce evidence capable of informing national policy rather than simply generating a collection of successful local stories.
[FIGURE 6.1 — FROM DISCOVERY TO DEMONSTRATION AND NATIONAL LEARNING]
An iterative pathway from regional inquiry and evidence, through feasibility and partner decisions, to limited demonstration, independent evaluation and national consideration. Decision gateways should make clear that progression is conditional rather than automatic.
6.6 Evaluation, Additionality and Public Value
Independent evaluation should be integral to the design of DevolvED from the beginning, rather than commissioned after programmes have been implemented.
Its purpose would extend beyond establishing whether activities have been delivered or participants are satisfied. It would examine whether the proposed approach produces identifiable educational, institutional, economic or social benefits, whether those benefits justify the costs incurred and whether the arrangements are more effective than credible alternatives.
The concept of additionality is particularly important.
If a regional partnership supports an initiative that institutions were already planning to undertake, its contribution may be limited. If the same outcomes could have been achieved through existing arrangements at lower cost, the case for a new institutional architecture would be weakened.
Evaluation should therefore consider what difference the proposed arrangements have actually made.
This would require a credible baseline, a clear account of the mechanisms through which change is expected to occur and an assessment of relevant alternative explanations. Depending upon the nature of an intervention, methods might include comparison with similar settings, longitudinal analysis, qualitative research, institutional case studies and assessment of costs and benefits.
Not every outcome can be measured with the same precision. Changes in educational participation may be observable within a relatively short period, while improvements in research capability, enterprise development or regional prosperity may take many years to emerge.
The evaluation framework should therefore combine shorter-term indicators of implementation and participation with longer-term measures of outcomes and capability.
It should also examine distribution.
A programme may improve average outcomes while leaving the least advantaged communities with little benefit. A regional innovation initiative may strengthen already successful enterprises without improving access to knowledge among smaller organisations. An educational partnership may create new opportunities for some learners while introducing barriers for others.
A proposition founded upon human flourishing must consider not only whether aggregate performance improves, but whose opportunities are expanded and whose circumstances remain unchanged.
The experience of participants would also matter. Learners, families, teachers, institutional leaders, employers and community organisations may identify practical consequences that are not apparent in administrative data.
Their evidence should inform the interpretation of outcomes without replacing the need for rigorous analysis.
The evaluation of governance would require equal attention. Researchers should examine whether responsibilities remain clear, whether decision-making is timely, whether institutional independence is respected and whether the costs of coordination are proportionate to the benefits achieved.
A partnership that improves communication but substantially increases administrative burden may not represent an effective reform.
Similarly, a governance arrangement that appears efficient but weakens transparency, public participation or accountability would conflict with the underlying principles of DevolvED.
Independent evaluators should therefore be able to report unfavourable findings, identify unintended consequences and recommend modification or discontinuation.
The credibility of the proposition would be strengthened, not weakened, by a willingness to learn from evidence that challenges its original assumptions.
[POP-OUT 6.2 — THE TEST OF PUBLIC VALUE]
The measure of success is not whether institutions have agreed to cooperate, but whether their cooperation creates benefits that would otherwise have been difficult to achieve — and whether those benefits justify the resources and responsibilities involved.
6.7 Decision Gateways and the Discipline of Progression
A staged approach would allow DevolvED to develop through evidence and informed commitment rather than through an assumption that each phase must inevitably lead to the next.
Decision gateways would provide opportunities for national government, regional leaders and participating institutions to assess progress, examine risks and determine whether continued investment is justified.
The gateways should be genuine, with the possibility of modification or discontinuation where evidence does not support further development.
The first gateway would follow initial Discovery and concern whether the proposition warrants more detailed design. Decision-makers would examine the regional evidence, the willingness of relevant organisations to participate, the compatibility of proposed arrangements with existing responsibilities and the potential additionality of a Regional Education Strategy and the two agreements.
A positive decision would authorise further development, not establish a presumption that implementation must proceed.
The second gateway would concern readiness for demonstration. Before commencing substantive activity, partners would need to agree the scope of proposed initiatives, the authority under which decisions would be made, the resources available, the safeguards required and the arrangements for evaluation.
Where the National–Regional Partnership Agreement or REPA remained under negotiation, the limits of existing commitments would need to be made explicit. No organisation should be represented as bound by an agreement it had not authorised.
A third gateway would follow an appropriate period of demonstration and evaluation. The central question would be whether the model produces sufficient educational, institutional and public value to justify continuation, adaptation or wider consideration.
Findings should distinguish between benefits attributable to specific projects and those associated with the partnership architecture. They should also identify the circumstances in which the model appears most useful and the limitations that would need to be addressed before considering wider adoption.
Table 6.2 — Proposed decision gateways
The final gateway would be a matter for national policy rather than an automatic consequence of regional success.
Even a promising demonstrator would not establish that identical arrangements should be introduced throughout England. Different regions possess different governance settlements, institutional capabilities and development needs.
National government would need to assess which principles are transferable, which arrangements depend upon local circumstances and whether any proposed changes to statutory duties or funding frameworks are justified by the available evidence.
The discipline of progression is therefore fundamental to the credibility of DevolvED.
A proposal that cannot be modified in response to evidence is not a serious programme of public reform. It is an assertion of institutional preference.
6.8 From Regional Evidence to National Policy
The potential national contribution of DevolvED lies in the development of evidence that could inform the evolving relationship between central government and regional leadership.
If a demonstrator establishes that a Regional Education Strategy improves the coherence of decisions, that a National–Regional Partnership Agreement strengthens cooperation between government and the mayoral authority, and that REPA enables institutions to collaborate more effectively, the findings could provide a basis for wider policy consideration.
Such consideration should begin with the principles and mechanisms shown to be valuable, rather than assume that the precise institutional arrangements of one region should be replicated elsewhere.
A national framework might eventually establish expectations for the development of Regional Education Strategies, the responsibilities of mayoral strategic authorities in relation to educational opportunity and the arrangements through which government engages with regional priorities.
It could also provide guidance on the development of separate national–regional and regional partnership agreements, including their relationship with existing statutory duties and institutional governance.
The degree of standardisation would need to be carefully judged, preserving national entitlements and accountability while allowing regions to respond to their distinctive circumstances.
One possible longer-term reform would be a statutory duty upon relevant mayoral strategic authorities to prepare, publish and report against a Regional Education Strategy.
Such a duty could give greater durability and democratic visibility to the educational dimension of regional development. However, its desirability would depend upon the powers and resources available to strategic authorities, the relationship with existing statutory bodies and the evidence that such a requirement would produce benefits beyond voluntary arrangements.
A duty to cooperate among relevant organisations might also warrant consideration, but should not be advanced without examining the implications for institutional independence, administrative burden and the responsibilities of national government.
These are questions for subsequent policy development, not assumptions upon which Discovery should be founded.
The immediate national opportunity is more modest, but potentially significant.
Government could support an evidence-led exploration of whether education and human capability should occupy a more explicit place within regional strategy, and whether structured relationships between national government, regional leadership and institutions could improve outcomes.
A carefully designed Discovery programme could provide evidence about the strengths and limitations of existing arrangements, the practical value of the proposed agreements and the conditions necessary for meaningful collaboration.
A subsequent demonstrator, if justified, could test whether these arrangements produce additional public value.
The wider ambition would be to establish a basis for national learning: an understanding of how different regions might connect education, research, enterprise and public services more effectively while retaining the responsibilities and freedoms that protect quality, accountability and institutional integrity.
6.9 The Next Step: An Invitation to Investigate
The practical next step proposed by DevolvED is the joint scoping of a time-limited Discovery programme involving relevant national government representatives, prospective regional leadership and willing educational and institutional partners. Its initial purpose would be to agree the questions requiring investigation, identify the organisations whose participation would be necessary or valuable, establish the relevant legal and financial boundaries, and determine the governance, resources and evidence required for a credible inquiry. This would not constitute approval of the proposed regional architecture or a commitment to subsequent demonstration. It would establish the conditions under which the proposition could be examined seriously and proportionately.
A jointly agreed scoping exercise could produce a concise Discovery prospectus setting out the issues to be investigated, the proposed workstreams, the responsibilities of participating organisations, the anticipated resources, the approach to independent evaluation and the decision criteria governing further development. It would also consider whether Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent provides an appropriate setting for such work, or whether a different geography or comparative approach would offer stronger evidence. The decision to proceed to substantive Discovery would rest with the organisations possessing the necessary authority and resources, and participation by independent institutions would remain subject to their own governance and approval processes.
The significance of this invitation is that it offers a disciplined response to an ambitious national proposition. DevolvED does not ask government to accept that a new settlement is necessary, that the proposed instruments are sufficient or that institutional cooperation will automatically produce better outcomes. It asks whether these questions deserve systematic examination in the light of the opportunities and challenges presented by the next phase of English devolution. If the evidence supports further development, the proposition could progress through carefully bounded demonstration and independent evaluation. If it does not, the findings should inform modification or discontinuation. In either case, the process could contribute to a more informed understanding of how education, research, enterprise and public services might strengthen the relationship between human development and regional prosperity.
The ultimate test is not whether DevolvED succeeds in establishing new institutions or agreements, but whether it helps government and its partners discover arrangements through which people and places can achieve more than existing systems readily allow. That is the purpose of Discovery and the basis upon which the proposition should be judged.